I’m not disagreeing with anything in your article nor the science presented. I think it’s good to be skeptical, ask questions, and decide what’s true/untrue/exaggerated/unsubstantiated/outright lies/etc.
Just wanted to add, from personal experience, my body definitely kept the score when I failed to grieve the death of my infant son in 2003. I tried to avoid grief for 20 years and my body did not go along with that plan. I had several physical issues that surfaced and after I worked through my grief, those issues resolved.
I agree to both points here - I think it’s important to be skeptical of scientific studies, particularly in a field such as psychology which has numerous well-known issues with reliable results. However, I feel that it’s wiser to say that the science is not definitive one way or another rather than insisting there’s no merit to the book at all.
Well, okay. But the issue here is not that "science" is making dubious or untenable claims. Rather, it is that van der Kolk himself is citing scientific studies to back up his claims that don't actually back up his claims.
not everything in life should be science. your experience is lived and intuitively you felt in your body that the traumatic event challenged you for so long. people who only believe in science or intuition are extremists and don't understand that life is infinitely nuanced. your experience is valid and you are brave for sharing it.
Thank you Vereya. I agree science isn't everything, especially when we're talking about grief. Sure there can be scientific studies about grief and how people experience it but science will have a hard time putting parameters on grief. As you said, it's infinitely nuanced. Love that.
Sure, nuance is absolutely needed, but so is truth. If a theory has limited basis in objective reality, then how well is it really going to help people?
Very sorry for your loss. I heard it phrased once that the brain keeps the score and the body is the scoreboard. Your experience makes sense, and with many others like it, it makes sense that VDK would be as popular as he is. He clearly tapped into something important that needed to be addressed. But he may have done that while still being wrong about some important things.
"He clearly tapped into something important that needed to be addressed."
Yeah, I have a bit of beef with the OP over this. The average person doesn't know an amygdala from an insula, and doesn't need to. The average person won't remember those kinds of details.
OP kinda... misses the point. Which probably also explains why OP thought the book would fade into obscurity: OP was focused on scientific details, so they didn't understand why the book was meaningful for people. OP is talking science, but the science is mostly not what's drawing people to the book.
So if you're going to argue with TBKTS, for most of us, it's more useful if you focus on the parts of the book that actually *impact* us. Takeaways for the average person:
- what counts as trauma? How endemic is it?
- the existence of the body-mind connection
- the way trauma can have long-lasting impacts on mental and emotional health
- how can we treat/resolve PTSD
Or, takeaways with *emotional* impact for the average reader:
- it's ok that that Bad Stuff that happened to you is still impacting you today
- you can heal, and you have some agency there; the power to direct your healing
Hi Jennifer. I am a certified Thanatologist and grief doula and have supported hundreds of bereaved through their grief journey. We know that grief is a physical, spiritual, emotional and social experience that also re-wires our brain. I was sad to hear about the death of your baby and wanted to acknowledge the courage and compassion it takes to process this giant loss. ❤️
You are opening up a hornets nest here, but you surface a real issue.
The reason the book is so resonant with people is the experience that unresolved pain does seem to “lodge itself” (specifically avoiding technical terms) in the body. Moreover, curiosity about the unconscious responses your body has to stimuli may be healthy and help resolve somatic issues.
Your article suggests that there may be an attribution issue, and I don’t quarrel with that.
The two issues as I see it:
1. The dominance of neuroscience right now is not fully earned. Much of the research that correlates lived experience with chemical pathways and neurological imaging is unsupportable hogwash, like understanding software design by x-raying a computer chip while it is running.
2. The book errs because it pretends it is not a psychology book and tries to be a neuroscience book. It would have been a better book simply if he had not tried to do that. As you astutely point out, the studies don’t really back up his assertions.
I'm sorry for your loss Jennifer. I had a similar experience. I tried to avoid grief after my 12 year old daughter died. It took 20 years to catch up to me also, and catch up to me it did. The trauma work of van der Kolk and Mate have helped me immensely along with the help of a compassionate trauma informed therapist.
Thank you Janalyn. I'm sorry for your loss as well. From a fellow avoider's perspective, it seems when grief catches up to you, it hits even harder because of all that pent up momentum. I'm so glad you found help, especially with a grief and trauma informed therapist. 💙
First, I am so sorry for the loss of your infant son. How tragic for you and your family. I cannot even properly imagine how you must have felt. You have my deepest sympathy. What I want to say is not to diminish your suffering, the psychological or physical suffering that has come from not processing your grief. But how do you know for sure that this is what caused your health issues? Your experience is anecdotal. What would prove your claim that they are connected is a research study that has been peer reviewed and given the nod for publication. Then, to further enhance its authority in this subject would be for someone to do the same type of study on the issue and come up with the same results. This is not to diminish your suffering and the psychological suffering that has come from not processing your grief.
I appreciate your interest and don’t take offense by your questions Kathie. But I have to disagree that you could do multiple research studies of people in grief and those studies would “come up with the same results” thus proving the way grief impacts people. Grief isn’t a math problem or something you can find an answer to like a riddle. Human beings are infinitely complex… and so is the way they love and the way they grieve.
Absolutely, people are very different. And no, it’s not about math, but most of what we know for sure about a myriad of human behaviour comes from qualitative research, looking for themes, gathering them together, looking for patterns etc. And yet still, they are generalizations, and some people just don’t fit in those patterns.
I think the author was not suggesting that the 'body doesn't keep the score'. But rather that van der Kolk failed to prove this, and more specifically he claimed trauma happened in every minor inconvenience. Which actually take away from experiences like yours here.
He is saying being a baby with an ambilical cord around your neck is the same as what you have experienced.
I also believe the author and the book he is citing is specifically claiming that van der Kolk's is commiting gross academic dishonesty. Because were these claims of his true he would've written a research article and let it be peer reviewed.
He did not, he published a book to the general public who does not know any better and that in a culture where victimhood is championed. Giving those 'victims' more reason to not take responsibility for themselves. He knows he would make money because of this - cause it sounds nice to be validated.
The claim that “only the outdated therapist uses CBT as their primary intervention”… I would like to see sources for that. Now, “first-wave CBT,” I would agree that few therapists still use those approaches. So much research is still being done on various versions of CBT and CBT-derived therapies (e.g., ACT, DBT, CPT, on and on), that I highly doubt this person’s claim
Knowledge is indeed power, and you don’t know me any better than I know you. I honestly wasn’t trying to insult you or your extensive experience with trauma.
I agree with you 100% that CBT is NOT a standalone treatment for PTSD. Never said it was. *I* don’t use it to treat PTSD; I obtained extensive training and supervision in other modalities. I simply argued against your statement that CBT is completely outmoded and therapists who use it are outdated. You did not specify “for PTSD.” It was a blanket statement.
CBT is certainly not the only tool in my therapeutic quiver—and it’s an important one, though again, as you more than rightfully point out, not for trauma in adults. And while CBT may be “easy to teach” (arguable, at least to teach well), it is far from easy to learn to do in a way that is personable and allows a therapist to really connect with a client and make a difference for them. In my opinion, therapists listing their “specialties” on Psychology Today list 10-20 therapy modalities is more “proof” that people think a two-day PESI course makes them qualified to list it as a modality they know and use well than evidence that CBT is outmoded. I personally don’t trust that a therapist who lists more than perhaps 5 modalities really knows them thoroughly and uses all of them competently. It’s incredibly difficult to know even that many well enough to use them regularly and competently.
Finally, having an undergraduate degree in molecular biology, a masters in science journalism, and over a decade as a well-respected science journalist under my belt, as well as a graduate degree in psychology, I’m probably more knowledgeable than most therapists I know about using http://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov and better equipped to read said papers with a critical eye. Published—and even peer-reviewed—hardly means without fault. Science itself is an iterative process, and what we thought we knew for sure today may be considered ridiculous in 10 years.
Sure, sure, but just because many therapists use purple-hat modalities like EMDR and IFS and hypnotherapy doesn’t mean they are actually backed up by good clinical research. Meta-analysis shows that all modalities of therapy work roughly equally well, and you can dismiss Can’t all you want, but it is the most robust of all modalities in terms of research.
There are many woo-woo therapists who offer hypnosis, past-life regression therapy, and other New Age nonsense, so it’s reasonable to be skeptical of the field when they continue to train therapists in modalities that really have no strong evidence base for them yet.
I do know what you're saying and while that's all true I also feel that saying it to someone who is grieving the loss of a child (which is the ultimate loss and one I witnessed my parents experience when my brother died) isn't actually helpful. Obviously the word “trauma” gets thrown around a lot in the world we live in now and I think it can be a real disservice to people, but I think the opposite can also be true. Colonialism has polluted everything for sure. But here we are. And I think there is a time to say that your “trauma” is just internalized colonialism and a timely to not say it.
Good takedown of bad science of Trauma. But speaking from experience, trauma can cause chronic stress and mental disfunction. It can fuel feedback loops that make life incredibly hard and painful, which is stressful, which makes it worse. And prolonged chronic stress does cause terrible health problems.
Your point about some people being predisposed to trauma is very important. It's very unequal between people. But this supports the idea that more people have trauma than recognize it. We have a cultural idea of trauma (something horrific happened to you). But the cause of trauma is overwhelming negative feelings, which depend on how sensitive you are. A sensitive person, and children in general, are more easily traumatized. For example I read a story of someone traumatized because he was falsely blamed for something as a kid and his dad didn't believe him. He depended on his dad to protect him, so it felt like a deep betrayal to not be trusted when he was scared and upset and telling the truth.
The severity of trauma also depends deeply on what happens after the bad experience. If you return to wholeness and safety (acceptance, understanding, care), you can fully express the pain and let it pass. It will leave and imprint but rarely a crippling one. But if you don't have anyone you feel safe being vulnerable with, it's terrifying and overwhelming. That's why losing trust in your family is so dangerous. It can spiral into getting more traumatized. This kind of trauma can start with a small seed and get very bad. I speak from experience.
Trauma varies in severity, so depending on what bar you set, lots of people have trauma. I agree that the point of revealing that shouldn't be to get people to obsess over painful childhood experiences. It's to help people see the conditioning in their mind that keeps them afraid, disconnected. Those can be known as feelings in the body, no memories required. And connecting with those feelings, sharing them with others, helps bring people back to wholeness.
Is there a GOOD science of trauma? If so, please would you share any literature or papers you may have written or suggestions for further reading and research. Thank you.
Good question. It would have to begin with debunking the fallacy that trauma is a thing, which it is not. Trauma is a word we use for a context. Trauma cannot cause anything any more than crime or play can cause anything. And looking for the causes of a context like trauma is similarly futile. We're not going to make any headway until we address the logical typing error errors in the way trauma is discussed.
I was brought up in a horrific environment that left my siblings and me with an abundance of issues to resolve, but I was the one who ended up with clearly diagnosable complex PTSD (yes, I know that’s not in the DSM), but to the point of being predisposed, I’m also the one with an Enneagram 6 wing 5 personality type — I’m essentially a fear based over-thinker…. So was it my personality type that set me up to develop cPTSD, and might I have walked more easily out of the early years if I’d been, say, a type 9?
I very much agree that the severity of how we carry overwhelming events has much to do with how loved and safe we feel afterwards. If there’s no one to go to for comfort, shelter, and guidance, the fear and mistrust are carried forward — as trauma…
You are clearly into and attached to the trauma narrative. Your example of the boy and not being believed paints people as being so weak. Did the adult boy truly believe that he was beyond question or that he did not lie sometimes. Whenever I hear stories like this I think what’s this scmuck trying to cover up while seeking solace in “daddy didn’t believe me”.
But then I come from a world best capture by this expression - “if you see a boy hit him, because if he hasn’t done anything wrong, he’s about to”
I'll respond with the hope that you are actually curious, and not just here to dismiss others perspectives. I agree that attachment to trauma narratives is dangerous. I have struggled with it. What makes it dangerous is the victimization, the blame of the other and helplessness of the self. I was really emotionally fucked up by the consequences of my trauma (because I neglected myself). I really wanted to blame someone and insist it shouldn't have happened. But I eventually realized that what happened to me wasn't so bad, and it turned out so terribly because my reaction impaired the healing process. I was a kid, I didn't know what I was doing of course. The point is that trauma doesn't have to be someone's fault. And yet it exists and is worth understanding. It's hard to do that without a story of what happened. I agree that people aren't so weak that any bad experience traumatizes them. Nor are people so innocent that they won't blame others for the consequences of their own actions, and forfeit their agency in the process. But people have moments of weakness, of raw painful fear and distress. And in those moments, it's very important to receive care and understanding from the people you are close to. I can't speak for the boy because I don't know him, only that story. But even if he were a liar sometimes, he could still have been hurt by being untrusted in his moment of vulnerability. You are right to say that all people do wrong. We all have the potential and the tendency for evil. We all engage in conflict and hurt each other. And sometimes that creates trauma. It's all perfectly natural and not anyone's fault. So I'm not saying parents can raise healthy children with no trauma by being 100% nice and trusting all the time. They will get taken advantage of. It is wise and important to engage in conflict with their children. To use power over them, even when they find it scary and painful. But being aware of how trauma works helps you to prevent and heal it when it does happen. Subtle differences in attitude can make a big difference in regards to preventing trauma. For example really listening to kids and trying to understand their feelings and perspective (instead of being dismissive) helps. Fostering trust, care, and understanding helps, even if its always imperfect. It's worth trying to heal, trying to take care of each other. I hope you realize you don't have to choose between being naive and being an asshole
Yes I agree with everything you have said. However the trauma narrative and assumption is really unhelpful and lends itself to that ever present tendency in human towards deceit. Particularly of ourselves. But in every other way I agree with you.
For years, the “trauma narrative” gave me a reason for not fully engaging in a life that frightened me, but it also protected me until I was ready to. I was a victim because overt abuse (physical, emotional and sexual) at the hands of my parents had done huge damage to my ability to trust both the world around me and even myself. As I slowly began to understand how it had all altered my thoughts, feelings, and behavior, I was slowly able to place the harms in my past, understanding that I am most likely safe now, and that what happened was truly not my fault. I began to understand that I had both the power and the ability to live a life that was not based on fear. A huge turning point in my healing came when I realized that without the trauma, I felt empty, vulnerable, and feared that I was losing my identity. I’m still in the process of allowing all that to exist while slowly taking steps to trust and believe in the parts of myself that carried me out of the trauma situation at age 15, toward what I've made into a good life. I am so much more than my trauma, but was unable to understand that while in a vulnerable victim role. I’m learning now to honor myself as a survivor.
An aside: It feels to me that Tom Carson’s remarks here are about small t traumas, not the huge ones that make even sleep dangerous throughout one’s childhood.
And yet here you are, a living example of how being exposed to negative things like violence, neglect, disregard and dislike usually means people end up disliking themselves and disliking others. They also usually engage in violence, neglect, disregard and dislike. Monkey see, monkey do. Hope you've been shown some kindness and love in your life. Being horrid because "I had a hard time so everyone deserves a hard time" is such an exhausting and lonely place to be.
If it was worth van de Kolk's time to write a book full of scientific half-truths and outright lies, it's worth Everett's time to write about those issues. The book would not have been half as persuasive if it didn't have all those "sources" that didn't match the studies.
That has basically nothing to do with the truth or falsity of his theory! You could write a book about how the moon landing was real with a ton of terrible scientific evidence and people would critique it.
Beth, do you understand the concept of lived experience? It is the opposite of science. The whole point of science is to figure out ideas that can be replicated and negated, and that comes from seeking the objective. Just because the ideal objective is not attainable doesn't mean that's not the goal. When you use the phrase lived experience, what you're doing is telling the world that you have absolutely no idea how to formulate ideas that stand up to testing. Without the ability to test, we have no capacity to differentiate between physical evidence and dillusion.
LMAO the same people who were condemning others for not taking the experimental jabs because "much science" are now attacking the author of this post because, despite him quoting ACTUAL scientific literature, it doesn't fit with their "lives experience". And, just like he said, it's all females and people with low testosterone. How interesting...
I dunno, I think it’s pretty important to call out when popular science/psychology books are totally misrepresenting the studies they are citing even if there are ideas in the work that have merit
First, a little context, I am trauma survivor and a trauma-informed care trainer. I read this book slowly and cross-referenced with many other concepts and trauma theories, and have discussed its contents extensively with therapists, educators, and survivors. I never got the sense that Bessel was attempting to portray himself or his work as being the gold standard of anything. But rather he was sharing his perspective on his life's work. As someone who felt like they had already healed their childhood trauma wounds prior to reading this book, I found my healing was able to deepen through reflecting upon the case studies shared and resonating with many of the stories of embodied practices, creating transformational healing experiences. It's one book on my Trauma informed care bookshelf. It's one book in an epic list of resources that we have access to. I think if you read the book with criticality in mind, you will take something away from it that is positive. I do appreciate his definition of trauma, which is the definition that I would begin every single trauma-informed care training with "traumatization occurs when both internal and external resources are inadequate to cope with an external threat."
Then we would unpack that definition. What is an internal resource? What is an external resource? How are those resources? Adaptive or maladaptive? Essentially, everyone is unique and we are shaped by our experiences and our conditioning to be more or less likely to be traumatized by a given external threat.
Differentiation of therapeutic modalities is essential. That is my key take away from Van Der Kolk's work. Everyone has a unique context and thus will need individualized trauma responsive care. CBT is great for some, EMDR is great for some, other cultural practices are effective too. Turf wars are unnecessary in the healing realm. And yet it occurs because humans have capacity for criticality. And that is what it is.
He says he did that--but his post doesn't sound like it.
Have you read the book? I have.
And I'm not a survivor of trauma, thankfully, but it's interesting that you automatically assumed I was, rather than just someone with expertise on the subject matter
What do you mean 'disingenuous'? The point was never that Bessel's work didn't have any merit but that the evidence he used to demonstrate whatever merit it may have had was rooted in outright falsehoods and representations. It's not about 'judging.' I've had severe PTSD, and so has my mother. I know the experience intimately. But I'd rather someone told me the truth about what I was experiencing and why, rather than spin shoddy logic to capitalize on my emotional readiness to make sense of my experience. You can absolutely write about trauma without lying. It feels utterly bizarre that you don't care that a book that's being read by thousands of people is filled with such falsehoods.
Is it possible that there are also people who feel _worse_ walking around in their own skin after being told that what they thought were just bad childhood experiences - or experiences they didn't remember at all - were actually *traumas* that have permanently altered their brains? I try to err on the side of "If it worked for you, it's not fake to you"; frankly, I'm willing to believe that even the most obvious BS *can* work in very specific circumstances. For instance, I know a woman who, as she tells it, kicked a heroin addiction using "bionetics" and (I might be misremembering this part) some sort of biofeedback/bioresonance emulator device. Am I going to undermine her progress by explaining that the "science" she's relying on is all fake, that there were other factors that helped her, that at best the machine was simply the object of projection/disavowal of her own internal power to kick the addiction? Of course not. Who knows, maybe the device really did do what it said it'd do, but as far as I could tell, there was no evidence that it did so *reliably*, for a wide range of people in a wide range of circumstances. It seems like the same thing may be happening here: This theory of trauma may have worked wonders for you and some other people - and is true in that sense - but it doesn't look like there's enough reliable evidence that it would do so for anyone else, as opposed to better-studied approaches.
From what I've learned in my own journey, trauma doesn't have to PERMANENTLY change the brain. Neuroplasticity shows that it is possible to retrain your brain, and it has also been shown that some cells can be regenerated through neurogenesis - specifically the ones in the hippocampus, which is where a lot of damage is done when you've lived through repeated trauma. Trauma is an injury, and eventually injuries can be healed - or at least get somewhat better. It's just a LOT of hard work.
True. And (not but) those who feel better disseminate the information as if it’s provable and scientifically verified. And even talk about as such. Which very much sacrifices
I posted a response with 5 peer reviewed papers and my own lived experience that refuted his argument and the author removed my note. I'm not convinced this "person" isn't AI.
LMAO it's the old "feelings don't care about facts". No wonder we live in such a post truth dystopia. It's no longer about what is true and logic. Only about "feelings". Such are the ways of the gynocracy...
I found CBT extremely traumatizing. I already had trouble labeling my feelings and thoughts, and CBT taught me to doubt myself even more. DBT, EMDR, trauma-informed therapy and somatic work are much better approaches IMHO.
Thank you for saying this. the whole point of science, bringing science and spirituality or the unseen together, is to put work out there and keep it evolving. It’s a mere idea that things build off of things- it’s the nature of our world. To critic so harshly is to throw the baby out with the bath water. This whole development in understanding trauma in the scientific world is emerging into general consciousness, not everyone is going to get it right the first time.
This trend to “discredit” Maté and van der Kolk is something we should be wary of—and highly cautious with. My problem with this take down of the ostensible “bad science” is that the writer ends with recommending … Alfred Adler of all people. One of the most discredited pseudoscientists in the entire field. There’s so much to tackle in this grift.
We have over 40 years of quality, cutting-edge neuroscience research—rigorous, peer-reviewed studies, hefty meta-analysis, and data from technological advances in neuroimaging—showing that the relational stimuli during the first three years of rapid neural migration, maturation, synaptogenesis, pruning, and myelin formation, absolutely impacts the wiring of our limbic structures (yes, the amygdala and insula, but also the hippocampus and hypothalamus). Neuroplasticity is also more pliable during adolescence and matrescence and patrescence. What happens to us in these years affects the brain as well as genetic expression. This is basic neuroscience. It’s not just Maté and van der Kolk.
This is shown in the academic literature out of Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child, Yale University’s Child Study Center, the University of Toronto’s SickKids’ Infant and Early Mental Health Promotion—and a litany of other prolific research centres.
To claim that since one can’t remember an event, it therefore has no effect on the developing brain is the height of scientific ignorance. Unfortunately many many folks before this writer have also used this vein of Tony Robbins self-improvement gospel to gain a following themselves. And despite the data, these people will always exist.
We can not deny that maternal sensitivity wires limbic structures in a healthy way, and causes epigenetic changes. An infant (0-3 in neuroscience) can not “self soothe” in the way the outdated behaviourists reprimanded parents with for decades. Infants breathe better, sleep better, and pump blood better when they are held. Skin-to-skin contact is well researched. Do adults remember this? No. Does it affect how their brains wire? Yes.
There is SO. MUCH. RESEARCH. on this. I have a list of citations on the above—none of which include Maté or Kolk. These are real scientists doing the lab work that science communicators cite. Personal experience, narrative, or bias should not discredit the rigorous work of these researchers—who do not have the time to educate the public on their findings.
Too many parents treat their babies, infants, and young children poorly because they “won’t remember” and this trend to tear down the advances we have made for children are deeply dismaying.
Thank you.., my god, as a PTSD specialist- I just didn’t even know where to begin with this post- and then the Adler comment? Spare me. Thank you for writing all this for me and saving me the energy. Th
I appreciate that Alison. It’s truly baffling (and exhausting!) given how much neuroscience and neuroendocrinology support critical-period closure. Pretty wild stuff. The most disappointing is that I stumbled upon this piece because a USC infant hormone researcher (and prolific “parenting” Substacker) shared it, leading my brain to explode with fury.
Why is Alfred Adler considered a pseudoscientist? I tried looking him up online and no mention of that. Only about his work in individual psychology and feelings of belonging and that his theories were different than Freud.
Hi May! Just saw this now, apologies. I’m very familiar with Bruer’s critique. There are areas I agree, but his work is mostly saturated with willfull blindness. I look at this more as an academic squabble and field confirmation bias: you see what you’re looking for. And Bruer looks over tens of RCT studies, neuroimaging data, and rigorous, quality peer-reviewed research in favor of complimentary—not contradictory as he finds it—findings. For starters, the neuroscience he’s looking at has much more to do with cognition and memory. IQ essentially. Most of the research supports that IQ is largely genetic. Playing Mozart in infancy won’t alter it. He’s correct there. Learning, additionally, is akin to a process called “conditioning” in the cognitive sciences. The premise is that repetition of the same thought/act reinforces the involved neurons to “fire and wire” together in response to specific stimuli. Synaptic and myelin formation happens across time and habituation. So yes, memory and learning are both a life-long process marrying stimuli, response and repetition. “What fires together wires together, and what don’t won’t” is how famed neuroscientist Carla Shatz summed up Donald Hebb’s theory and research. This is what Bruer’s critique tackles. The brain—from infancy into adulthood—is “plastic” and so responds appropriately to changing environmental and relational stimuli. He’s not wrong there either.
Where he IS wrong is in saying that the relational experiences/stimuli during the 0-3 years don’t lay the foundation for all of the above to happen. The brain is built similar to a house where the foundation matters for the stability of the upper structures. And that foundation—the brain stem and the limbic structures such as the amygdala and insula—are largely wired/closed around age 3. The neocortex (including the prefrontal cortex which is responsible for longterm planning, consequence weighing, and impulse control) are still being fired and wired until around age 25. It’s the area we see most neuroplasticity. BUT the early architecture of the limbic areas have more rapid neuron formation (and are more or less set for life) during the first three years.
Why this matters is because these structures are where our emotions, hormones, neuropeptides begin/have the most activity. If an early environment is chaotic, unpredictable, neglectful, abusive, or lacking in vital “serve and return interactions” of a parent warmly responding to a baby’s coos and cries, the limbic structures experience more stress (the cortisol cascade becomes more easily triggered) and less oxytocin (the hormone responsible for being “soothed”). That stress impacts all the above brain building processes. The brain may fire and wire neurons to be hyper reactive to stressors even when they aren’t present. This is well documented and well researched. A Greenberg lab (Harvard) paper, recently published in Nature, discusses this critical-period closure, noting, “In the months or years after birth, critical periods of learning in the brain are open, making the organ uniquely sensitive to information coming from the outside world. Experiences during this time have a lasting impact on the brain by sculpting neural connections that persist into adulthood. As a child or young animal matures, this heightened period of brain plasticity ends, as critical periods begin to close.” Bruer skips over all this work in favor of placing emphasis on the neuroplasticity of the neocortex.
When you see a critique of an expert or scientific consensus, it’s best to think of it as a school of fish. If most of the research points in one direction, and one paper darts off, you’re better suited to look at the bulk of conclusions over an offshoot one.
Here, you have one person saying “Hey the brain shows neuroplasticity into adulthood—so early experiences can be over-ridden!” while ignoring critical-period closure. The brain is a complex organ that forms in bursts, with specific ages being more susceptible to external inputs.
We can’t change how long our bones grow once we reach the height we’ll be as adults. But we can change or affect the tissue, muscle, weight that forms on top of those bones. Similar to this, we can’t nudge (far enough to be efficient) the limbic structures reactivity, or how they “fire and wire” in response to stressors (and the autonomic hormone response that happens within milliseconds of sensing a stressor). But we can change how we *think* about and act towards those stressors—through meditation, EMDR, somatic experiences, etc—as the neocortex, where these functions take place, is more plastic.
These choices and considered actions can help make our nervous systems a little bit more, or a little bit less, reactive. But they can’t change fundamentally to the core, as that foundation was laid in our first few years, including in the prenatal months. This is what Bruer misses with his overemphasis on neuroplasticity and underemphasis of critical-period closure.
I was supposed to read this book for my "trauma informed" classes. I quit reading the book after the first 10 pages. (while I'm required to do a certain amount of trauma informed training, I find most authors and instructors have never faced trauma themselves a day in their life and so have no clue what they're talking about.)
90% of psychology/sociology is complete BS and studies can't be replicated, because each human perceives things so differently. Get 10 witnesses to any situation and you'll get ten different POVs about that incident. Some will have a "fight or flight" response (could lead to 'trauma') and some could see it as no big deal.
I'm not saying trauma DOESN'T exist. It does. Falling off your bike and breaking your arm might have been the 'worst thing to ever happen to you, and thus was 'traumatic.' But acting like the body isn't an amazing organism designed to heal (mentally, spiritually, and physically) from such events is where psychology fails. We are resilient creatures. (Until we have that resilience trained out of us through learned-helplessness.)
If any of these yahoos actually CARED about "healing your trauma" (rather than selling books and making $$$), they would talk about how the news media, 24/7 TV, digital devices, etc. actually train us to operate out of sympathetic nervous system (Fight or Flight) rather than existing within our parasympathetic nervous system, which is where all our daily functions (eating, sex, sleep, etc) are controlled. And THAT'S where Alternative and Complementary Medicines (Healing Touch, Meditation, chiropractor, etc.) can have a huge impact, because it reminds your body what it feels like to NOT be in "fight or flight" mode. (None of those modalities are cures for anything, by the way. They just help your body return to its natural state, then the body - not being controlled by 'fight or flight' is much more likely to take care of itself, as it was designed.)
Oh man I felt the same way. I actually purchased it from Amazon, skimmed it and returned it after I realized there was not a single important thing in the book. Do yoga, spend time in nature, keep a regular sleep schedule, maintain friendships. No shit? That stuff is necessary whether you have trauma or not. It doesn’t do a single thing for those with severe trauma and PTSD.
Agape …interesting choice of name and meaning thereof.. Hope you have some success with your project…good to have a variety of viewpoints on the vast topic of Jesus …..in the meantime, you have important things to do by the sound of it .and we all know that Life is a Lifelong Pursuit. Good wishes.
It’s been in the pipeline for about 20 years. 🤣. It’s gone through about 5 iterations. The current one is “Life in the Gaps: a journey through the Paschal Triduum.”
But I highly doubt I’ll ever publish, so I write on Substack and serve as a Spiritual Director and Healing Touch Practitioner.
Gabor Mate does address the impacts of modern technology, the tv hr news, digital divices on stress to some extent in the myth of normal, and he recommends another book, i-minds, that goes into much more detail on the issues.
Interesting perspective. Thank you for sharing! I'm a holistic nutritionist and am finding nervous system work to be the most important foundational work for a plethora of things.
This didn't post my reply to the right thread for some reason - sorry about that!
I’m a healing touch practitioner. But I’ve actually studied more of the sciences and psychology because of my spiritual direction work. In today's society most of the problems I encounter (Mental, Spiritual and even some physical) are due to nervous system issues.
Note my words ‘something else’ and ‘researched the subject further’ ….it’s quite easy to misinterpret or misunderstand someone else’s opinions. Time to disengage from this thread for once and for all.
It does….and until someone on here or elsewhere writes something else having researched the subject
further, I guess it’s good to have some insight into trauma thinking and understanding….thus far. It’s also good for us all to cultivate empathy and compassion ….in any case!!
If you mean research about the nervous system, a lot of that does exist - which is what makes some of this 'trauma informed' psychobabble frustrating. If you mean in regards to specific Complementary Medicine Modalities, you need to look at the research available within each specific area, since getting grants to have research posted on sites like the NIH are few and far between. (But you can still find some posted there.)
I'm sorry you have experienced all of those things. You are right, it is very complex. And"Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs" absolutely needs to be considered. I'm sorry if by not mentioning basic needs being met left you with the impression that I didn't think those were important.
However, it is never either/or; it is always both/and. For example: if you are only ever operating out of your sympathetic nervous system (fight/flight), then your awareness of your Hierarchy of Needs actually shift, because all of those needs are controlled by your parasympathetic nervous system. Why would you care about eating, when you're constantly worrying about needing to run away and hide? Or fight to the death - If you're going to die, you have no need of food.
Yes, the government systems (across most countries) leave a great deal to be desired when it comes to anything that's not Western Medicine or involves Mental Health. And honestly most books like this one (and don't get me started on all the 'self help' books!) actually do more harm than good for those who try to encourage the governments to change how those services are used.
Yes, his trauma of being addicted to buying CDs. I (I'm an recovered alcoholic, from a family of alcoholics (it wasn't pretty) and I work in addiction support) found it really difficult to take that at face value, I mean I understand that any process can be an addiction but I had to put the book down for a while to process that. I am aware of his history and I'm not referring to that.
Perhaps, you didn't read all of this article, or the articles linked within it. There are other issues with Gabor Mate's works. I've attended several seminars that featured him. Given the hype about him I received leading up to the first one I attended, I was less than impressed. Maybe his earlier works were better. But this was back in late 2019. (Pre-COVID)
This honestly explains some of the nonsense that I see coming out of pop psychology and TikTok self-diagnoses. I was wondering why the word "trauma" was appearing everywhere in discussions of psychology for the past few years.
right, and don’t forget the christians and mormons and jahova witnesses and i could go on and on. all teaching to whip and beat and subdue their children, to be willing to walk their children up to the point of death in the name of some higher being. that taught their children they were sinful and deserving of hell, being exposed to some real fucked up shit (drink this pretend it’s blood), purity/rape culture.
religion is STILL RUNNING THINGS, and dividing whole nations, while causing countless wars and death. all being weaponized for power within government.
yeah there’s a shit ton of trauma. if you didn’t experience it, consider yourself lucky!
Social media likes to promote the idea that everyone has PTSD! It's not true"
Valid point. But I think it's fair to say that a larger-than-expected number of people have relational issues or maladaptive coping mechanisms that are partially caused by past trauma. Not quite so far as "everyone has PTSD", and more "most people have lingering problems caused by past trauma".
This. There’s such a big difference between childhood trauma and trauma experienced as an adult. Trauma doesn’t need to “re-wire” a child’s brain because it effects the original wiring as it’s created. Kids’ nurture experiences determine things like gene expression, so no surprise trauma at that age could affect the body.
thank you so much for this piece — i found it a refreshing perspective. one part that stood out was the mention of dave asprey attributing his ptsd to birth trauma.
i’ve given birth twice in the last four years, & as part of that, i’ve spent a lot of time learning about birth physiology. a nuchal cord is fairly common, occurring in around 20–30% of all births. in most cases, it’s not harmful. babies aren’t breathing air yet; they’re still receiving oxygen via the placenta, so unless the cord is tightly compressed (rare), there’s no danger. in most cases, it’s simply looped off by the birth worker during delivery.
what struck me is how something so normal can, over time, be reinterpreted as traumatic — especially through the lens of books or frameworks that suggest trauma lives in the body, even if we don’t remember it. i say this as someone who carries very real trauma. the more i’ve reflected on my past, the more i’ve come to believe in the chicken-and-egg theory. the more you look for trauma, the more you find it — sometimes even in places it may not really exist. i’ve noticed how easy it is, when processing old experiences, to reshape them into something they maybe never were. it’s a strange thing — trying to honour your pain while also being honest about what really happened.
i’m so grateful for writing like this that invites nuance, curiosity, & a bit more grounded thinking — especially in such a tender, often polarised, space.
Psychology is pseudoscience. This is why 70% of social science studies cannot be replicated. The reason being is that we are all very different. Each group that you study is going to give different results. Plus the person performing the research is fallible, may already have a result they want to achieve in mind, and their funding may hinge on getting that result.
But that's not a reason to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
And you're right, trauma alone doesn't cause mental illness. But its not just genetics either. Its both.
Also, PTSD, like all mental illness, festers in isolation. When we have communities to help us process traumatic events, theyre less likely to linger, but we live in a very isolating world today.
There are so many psych treatments and medications because we are all so nuanced that its like throwing darts at a board. Bessel dismisses CBT in The Body Keeps the Score, but it works very well for many people.
Also, he tells an anecdote of EMDR completely eradicating PTSD symptoms in a woman. EMDR doesn't work for everyone, and its just a half assed version of clinical hypnosis.
Exercise, go outside, eat clean, healthy relationships, and community do more for mental health than anything.
Every person I've ever known who is struggling isolated themselves. Get out of your own head. The world wants you to come kick it with us.
That said, some people are simply born with broken brains and absolutely need psych meds.
But the vast majority are suffering the consequences of a screwed up culture consumed by consumption. Its difficult to eat clean when everyone around you does not care. Moms do not give a shit about your diet. No choice but to refuse food and suffer the social consequences.
So many people are never outside, or believe that its going to make their face rot off. Sun exposure provides endogenous opioids. Endorphins.
The good news is that its a great time to be alive for the disciplined.
As a mental health therapist who has treated people for years, Trauma is real and healing one’s trauma does not go away with diet and exercise.
While I see my clients improve dramatically in their thinking, Behaviors, relationships, parenting and quality of life from
Therapy, people tend to then have the want and energy to lead healthier lifestyles.
The patriarchal myth that the need for therapy is just about Character flaws(pull up your bootstrap mentality pushed by our maga folk who claim. “I did it and I’m ok) is harmful to people suffering the effects of trauma and I would argue maga personalities tend to be sociopathic ( fear based, shame based, anger based and discrimination based) and extremely harmful to children and now the people of our country.
"Trauma is real and healing one’s trauma does not go away with diet and exercise."
Where was that claim articulated or implied in the article?
My takeaway from the article is that the book's author made a lot of very specific claims concerning trauma and the human body that aren't supported by the studies he cited. There have been many times when I found something useful and meaningful in a book or essay that turns out to contain some false or incorrect claims, or correct claims based on junk arguments, but that doesn't mean I don't appreciate it when those errors or misrepresentations are pointed out after the fact.
I was with you until you blamed it on patriarchy. Everything you hate is not automatically patriarchy. The institution of psychiatry was created by men in a patriarchal milieu.
Just because patriarchy is one of society’s problems doesn’t mean we should lazily just use the term as a label for everything we don’t like. It just dilutes the meaning into nothingness. Patriarchy is a social system. It doesn’t just mean say macho or hypernasculine. Maybe extreme machoness and hypermasculinity is averse to therapy but the general system of patriarchy, which is rule by men for the primary benefit of men, supports therapy just fine.
Yea it does. I've seen many such cases. The matriarchal myth that everyone is broken and needs therapy and infinite medications is just detrimental to ACTUAL human well being.
Someone told me once that psychology should be considered a liberal art and not a hard science and I must say I tend to agree … there are far too many unmeasurable and unseen external factors to be able to measure them with anywhere near the accuracy of other hard sciences
Edit: psychology IS a liberal art, but we have trouble still wanting it to have hard-sciences like easily replicable data .. sorry for wording that poorly
Which is why it is called a social science. Psychology is most certainly not an art - wherein postmodern notions of 'whatever you feel/all opinions are equal' apply. This is why, though most Universities have psychology depts, none label it as an arts subject. Psychology is the ongoing quest to discover reliable truths about the mind and brain - an organ which is the most mysterious and complicated thing we humans have ever come across, and which isobcviously roooted in objective phenomena. No surpise that the tools of science are not sufficiently developed to bring the surity you demand (really, what were you thinking; that the truths of the mind & brain should be easy to find?). The young field of psychology has come along leaps and bounds in recent years, and is slowly but surely meeting the crisis of replication etc.
By the way, Neither Gabor Mate nor Bessel Van der Kolk are psychologists - they are psychiatrists, medical Drs; and there is long history of these high status amateurs bungling into the field of psychology without good training. Starting with Freud.
Just so you’re aware- Social sciences fall under the umbrella of liberal arts…
my point is to distinguish it from the hard sciences- many seem to want the kind of hard data and precision sciences like physics and chemistry can achieve with psychology and thats just never going to happen. And many psychiatrists essentially operate as therapists and counselors within their profession as Mate and van der Kolk have clearly done . There’s a lot of crossover within mental health professions.
Indeed - in the US - though in the UK it's a 'Humanities' subject. No biggie, although I can't see how either term, art or liberal, fits psychology. In both countries psy is a social science - I think you'd agree that those protesting the label of the 'S word, simply don't understand what Science is (BTW: I meant to reply to Kezia Vida/jon Raiser rather than you!) One of the first things I was taught in science class (aged 9) was that everything we would be taught was at least a little wrong - the process of science being what it is will lead to ever more accurate ideas that replace the older. If we followed 'Occam's Raiser' no science would have ever got off the ground, as all initial thereories were risible and unreplicated.
I understand the crossover between the fields - my frustrated point is i) that many people dismiss psychology on the basis of dodgy psychological claims of people.... who are not actually psychologists; and ii) who lack a modern psychological education, are not well grounded in research methodology (as I suspect you know already, current psychology research methods are actually particularly good, and getting better, at applying scientific principles to humanities phenomena (the field has taken the replication crisis seriously, and learnt from it).
Evolution can’t be easily replicated either. I never get this argument for proving why some knowledge is useless. The scientific method isn’t the be all end all for knowledge being useful or worthwhile.
Excellent point “Also, PTSD, like all mental illness, festers in isolation. When we have communities to help us process traumatic events, theyre less likely to linger, but we live in a very isolating world today.” Most o the issues today are because of break down of the community
We begin as a fish. A parents’ nightmare or wish. Swimming within what feels an abyss. When our timeline is sparked, we ram. No more a fish, now we are pushed with a whoosh onto land. A baby. Still with no working legs to stand. We come forth as a lamb. Now we have landed upon Earth. What a birth! Have we been uniquely blessed or been cursed? Life might seem suspect and underhanded. Exactly where have we landed? Upon what sort of sordid planet? What of us is going to be required or demanded? Will we be strong like Bull? Or be seen as a cowardly calf with little to no soul. Just a joke and a laugh. Here to be someone else’s servant and staff. Either way we become split from the get go. Twins; one goes high and the other low. Both a Devil and an Angel speaking for the parts of our soul. While the body keeps score, No? Trying to discern what all we can know. Just how loud is our crow? When does the party start? When can we go? This confusion makes us emotionally crabby. Will we receive comfort or need to be grabby? My how our pinchers can be so sharp and stabby. Within us too is a tomcat; a tabby. Here comes our lion. An individual quest for our own truest Zion. An ego’s soul seeking the heavens. With a slot machine gamble. Big betting; lucky number sevens. Might cash in the cow. Eventually we’ll land on our ass with an ow. A clash of a titan without much class. Our feet will eventually need to touch grass. We shall sow the seeds for the harvest like a virgin. Still, the heart beats through this incursion. Focus upon health and work for discernment. Strike a balance between our many urges to ferment. Here the scales of justice enter into the equation. The power of self within a vast complex nation. So many disagreements between the generations. Pretty soon we require a respite, a soulful vacation. So we will slide into the depths of our sensations. Lurking with a scorpion’s prolonged patience. Contemplating the secrecy of sex and the death of relations. We might get lost here if we don’t change the station. So we’ll embark upon new situations. Allow our fires to spark! Hark, now we’re riding an arrow! Launched from the archer’s bow. Half human and half workhorse. Don’t you know? Oh how far we can travel and how much we can grow! And when we learn we can build! We can conquer and develop and drill. We can form formidable guilds. Banking the till. We don’t want God’s abundance spilled on those we’d much rather HE kill. We are mermaid tailed goats. We must be kings of the hills. Surrounding our castles with moats. Greatest of all time? Totes! Yet what’s up must one day come down. Before we go, take a good look around. We need to make our mermaid parts proud. And so, tumble bumble, we spill forth from this highflying crowd. Our splash might be quiet or loud. Once again we’ll need kin. A water bearer, releasing us into the quirky intelligence of our sin. A stop, drop, and roll and a renewal begins. We feel the spark! The ahh of our ark. Building technologies allowing all life to creatively embark. It’s the least we can do. For this melting pot stew. So we travel the spiral between losses and wins. Diving back into the oceans where we’re fish once again! Schooled this time, so now all of us win. The whole swath of us riding the waves of this most mystical spin.
What psychology is, however, is a new science. And it is actually fairly common for studies to be hard to replicate in new sciences because the techniques are still being worked out by practitioners.
Your whole comment illustrates that you don't really understand scientific logic.
Google Freud and Jung's connections to mysticism. Psychology is mysticism repackaged for a materialist science world. It will never be a hard science because humans are far too complex. Well, it might become hard science after transhumanism happens.
I should preface this eith: Theres a lot of truth to psych. My body reacts to certain situations in wacky ways. I've read a ton of psych books the past few years and its helped me immensely. But it has a lot of pitfalls. Namely, those who use it as an excuse to never change. The ones who see it as religion. Who refuse post traumatic growth.
They've been here many times. None of them understands that "That doesnt mean that we should throw the baby out with the bathwater" means that psychology is still valuable. But its merely a tool to help understand yourself and everyone else, not a panacea, and not a religion. And none of them want to do difficult things or change to get better. Their psych religion gives them an excuse instead of pushing them to do better. All psych treatments from EMDR to SSRIs are like throwing darts at a board. The DSM started with 100 pages, is now over 1000, and has pathologized EVERYONE.
It’s true it was a blase comment; but at the root the concept of psyche to me is immaterial and subjective at its core. So the idea that we can have a science of that, if you are a materialist, to me is an epistemological error. And of course western science, and western psychology, is dominated by a materialist epistemology. So yes we can have useful information from the framework of materialist science about those topics, but I don’t think it’s necessarily helpful, or really even capable of, answering fundamental questions of the psyche; ie why are we here? Who am I? How do I alleviate my suffering?
That’s why I call it pseudo science, it pretends to be able to answer questions that it can not. These are questions that do not have materialist science answers. The evidence of this is manifest in the reality of the failure of psychology and psychiatry to achieve mental wellness in the westernized population, and in fact the marked decline in wellbeing experienced after the rise of these “sciences”.
I do not ascribe any moral failing to deeply concerned and hardworking individuals who devote themselves to these paradigms, and to anyone who has a sincere desire to use that energy in a way that tries to meet the need for psychological healing in our world. I deeply believe that humans are for the most part doing their best with the hand they were dealt. But psychologists need to understand that the popularity and deep resonance among people of the body meets the score is evidence enough of its impact and psychological reality. We don’t need neurological evidence to “prove” something that so many people are experiencing and telling us they are experiencing.
No it’s not that. MRIs are a key diagnostic tool for neuropsychological research. What do they demonstrate, really? Namely, where blood is flowing or not in the brain. What does that mean? Reading How Emotions Are Made is helpful in this. I am not saying there is never anything useful found from the experiments, but at the core the questions of psychology are not scientific questions, or rather can not be answered by materialist science. For example, what can we point to in the physiology that shows someone has bipolar disorder? No answer currently, no test. Also, what is the psyche, how is it scientifically defined? What is an emotion, how do you measure it? What is happiness? To me the biggest demonstration that psychology is pseudoscience is how deeply terrible our psychological treatments are. If a cancer doctor had the same treatment success rate as psychiatrists have at curing the “diseases” they say they are curing, the cancer doctor would be put on trial for malpractice. Why is it different? We seem to want the rigor of science to put a rubber stamp on things but at the same time we allow for the “science” of psychological treatment to fail miserably, seemingly admitting to ourselves that the science isn’t the whole story, yet we cling to it. I’m sorry but look deeper at tools like brain scans, and at the science of things like emotions. It’s truly not nearly as rigorous as you might imagine.
would it be bad to be so? why is science end all be all anyway? do we function based on science most of the time? do you push the door harder when it's heavier because you know the physics behind it or because you naturally sensed to do so? intuition is not a stupid thing, it's the first thing leading to science and it's powerful
I appreciate that people like you think the way you do and go to such lengths to present your arguments- science and reason will ALWAYS be crucial to knowledge and progress.
I’ve never read the Body book, nor do I care for Mate, but I do and have undergone successful treatment for C-PTSD and was looking for you to mention Complex trauma above. You didn’t, which is fine, but demonstrates you’re just coming from a totally different experience and knowledge base than people who have (reportedly) related to and benefited from reading the Body book specifically.
I also looked for you to mention an absolutely excellent and reputable book, “The Practical Guide for Healing Developmental Trauma.” Heller (PhD) & Kammer (LMFT) and you also didn’t.
This book explains, discusses and instructs how to use neuro affective relational modeling for treating adverse childhood experiences ( which is how C PTSD develops). AKA the trauma you’re skeptical of.
Whether or not the Body book adequately references scientific evidence, trauma does, in fact, get stored in the brain and nervous system and manifests as C-PTSD.
In my opinion, you’ve chosen two weak (but admittedly popular) resources to attack, which again, is reasonable, but I simply don’t see the point in arguing against the experiences of so many who these sources have resonated with as helpful resources on their trauma healing journey.
Isn’t the real point to have a society of whole, happy people? And we are in the infancy of figuring out how to get there. It’s going to be imperfect and we need people like you to challenge our methods, but also, people like you to acknowledge (developmental) trauma exists and spend (more) time finding the reputable resources that adequately acknowledge it than zeroing in on 1-2 questionable ones and dissecting them to expose technicalities.
While the individuals writing these books may NOT be too far off Boomers / Gen X age, their 'wisdom' is purely fictional and designed to feed / create the zeitgeist which is the current overly self indulgent population. Humans have been experiencing bad births, poor upbringings, wars since first arriving on the scene. Somehow though, it's only the past 30 - 40 years which appears to have manifested in mass trauma, ADHD, PTSD (and the rest) diagnoses. Interestingly, for about the same length of time that poor ultra processed diets and chemicals have skyrocketed. You're a critical thinker, Joseph, stay that way.
Love this! We were told to just “deal with it” or “get over it” — only in recent years are there safe places and literature to discuss what we’ve known all along. Thanks for this!!
I very honestly feel that I come from a family line, on my maternal side, that embodied PTSD. At my generation, it is epigenetic. Every blasted one of us. It is only at this point that some of us are striving to create a new pattern, or, very frequently, choosing not to have children.
It’s almost as if we’re finally acknowledging it, diagnosing it. In my grandparents generation they just drank themselves to death or killer themselves in record numbers. I find it fascinating that people seeking healing is a problem for you.
Trauma, along with so many new-age problems have blossomed in "first-world" countries over the last few decades. I think there are many causes. First true existential concerns have largely disappeared in western society, the vast majority of people do not have to worry about enough food, water, shelter. We have to find other things to agonize over and there are thousands of experts ready to help us identify them, and by pure coincidence make a solid living from it. And yes, social media plays a role and the unfortunate victims are disproportionately young liberal leaning women. The trauma culture is a real factor and its prevalence varies widely geographically, by sex and by political leaning.
There are many people truly traumatized by serious life altering events and I do not belittle them or doubt that some are never able to identify or acknowledge that fact. For many others I believe the trauma industry is just another escape from agency.
Or, now that people finally feel safe because they dont have to worry about basic life necessities, traumas are coming up. If youre still in survival mode, your body doesnt feel safe to let all the old hurt come up so it can get rid of it. It is only in safety that you can start to notice the trauma that has been present all this time.
Trauma isn't a 'new-age problem' and it hasn't 'blossomed' over the last few decades. We just have new and better language for the lasting impact of adverse experiences. Yes, Trauma is overused and incorrectly attributed, but that doesn't take away the suffering of anyone who really experiences PTSD. I am grateful I am not in this cohort because I have seen enough of it to understand how debilitating it is.
There are a lot of assumptions and little actual study reflected in this comment. There is a good deal of writing about the psychological effects of various wars on men who returned, as far back as World War I, perhaps further. The symptoms described are consistent with PTSD. There is also evidence of the psychological effects of giving birth in literature such as, “The Yellow Wallpaper,” by Charlotte Perkins Gillman, written in 1892. Similarly, writings about the origins of the novel Frankenstein, and Mary Shelley’s life at that time, show evidence of the psychological impacts of losing a child. Being ignorant of these things does not mean they never happened. They’ve happened for centuries, but only recently been given a name and allowed out of the dark.
Exactly! All this trauma and PTSD bullcrap is the new religion. The same people who shame religions for dogma and "much sky daddy" are the same ones who worship the pseudoscience that is psychology and attack anyone who dares question it. If you have trauma the solution is simple, turn to God, eat well, exercise and live a life of integrity rather than rotting on a couch and taking meds and eating ice cream and slop and spending money on so-called therapy. But apparently such view - common sense - is considered extreme these days. Oh well...
This just in, man disproves the existence of water. Thats how this reads. I can understand if you’re fed up with people branding trauma instead of learning how to clean it up but… I know that water exists.
Ha! To expand, man observes 4x4 patch of asphalt on burning hot day, disproves existence of drowning victims, proposes they were simply born with an unusual non-water fluid already in their lungs, reminds us of the quality evidence base for lung drainage.
Can there not be a variety of ideas and concepts and interpretations of Trauma? I’ve worked in the field for many years and one thing is very clear - Trauma is a many coloured ‘thing’ and there are various ways to interpret it, work with it and understand it…and if we can gain more insight into it, there is no reason why not…. Rothschild and others have pioneered some (necessary) ways to THINK about trauma and if we become more compassionate and understanding about it, perhaps more people can be helped. Finally, Theory Is only the starting point of training and treatment.
Trauma does to you whatever you do with it. You can use it to grow or you can use it to decay, it's literally that simple. I had an alcoholic abuser buffoon of a father and a shitty childhood, but it eventually lead me to have a life where I work 5-10 hours a week and make more than enough and go wherever, whenever, because I couldn't stand the thought of someone having control over me.
I’m glad to have read your comment as I have achieved things I wanted to despite several health issues and bounced back, up to a point, over the years. Family and emotional issues included. Looking back and feeling satisfied helps me right now but it doesn’t mean the down side isn’t still there and it crops up now and then. Seeing the physiological reasons helps me, but it’s not everyone’s cup of tea for various reasons. I feel it actually helps us. I think that’s one reason my issues were due to my mum who still says never mind after saying how down she feels. I’m seeing her reasons in a different way learning more about what/if/why.
You're right, there absolutely is a downside. But given that we can't change what has already happened, I think it's best to focus on the positives after learning the why - I agree that knowing the cause is important. These days in my opinion way too many people blame trauma for everything negative in their lives and overanalyze, which is understandable up to a level, but taking control over one's life and accepting that messed up things did happen to us yes - but they are in the past now is crucial for a good life, because the future is completely in our control even if it may be hard to admit in some cases. Learning emotional regulation was what helped me most with dealing the downsides of trauma, I highly recommend it to anyone. And thank you for sharing your thoughts!
It’s good to share! I’m sure you know exactly what I mean… Apparently my family look up to me because I’m so chirpy and and deal with my health issues and it helps them to buck up and deal with theirs, right now I’m beginning to think, fine, do what’s good for yourself but I’m not responsible for your emotions! It makes me feel pressured in a way. But definitely loved. This latest almost fashionable way of finding out why you feel like you do and how to deal with it and being broken, needing emotional help to deal with trauma does make me think hopefully it’s just a (money making?) phase, things will settle down again and level out - I mean this in a social psychology way. Hopefully I make sense! Maybe I need more help… 😄
Blaming individuels and pretending that everything is in your hands is at best naïve and totally cruel (why not blaming those who cause trauma and the secondary victimization through mental health systems, institutions, lack of ressources and commmunity...which are failing again and again survivors) and or straight disingenuous. We are fooling ourselves, we have so close to no power on how things are turning and we are often exhausted to chase an illusion of control
Why is it cruel at all? Creating something positive out of something negative is cruel? Maybe you misunderstood what I meant. Either way, I'm not blaming anyone, and I'm not saying that trauma is good - I'm just saying that given that we cannot change the hurtful things that have happened to us in the past, we should focus on the future and do our best and be optimistic, because there is zero downside to that whereas dwelling on the past personally just made me miserable. I do agree that there's a lot wrong with the "system", and that's exactly why we should focus on doing what we can and giving ourselves the best possible life
It's not about luxury or affordability. He just pulled himself by his bootstraps and worked hard to improve his life instead of being lazy and just feeling like the victim and self-pitying.
Invalidating wasn't my goal, and I agree 100% that trauma does have a lifelong effect. My goal was to say that you get to decide the effect up to a pretty high degree, and can use the "fuel" that it left in a more positive way instead of looking at it as entirely negative, since you can't change the past but the future is in your hands. Your brain chemistry may forever be altered from it, but that's not necessarily an absolute negative. Again, all this said, I understand people who struggle because of trauma because I was one of them for a long time, so I'm not invalidating anything.
This entire article comes across as smug, reductionist, and clearly written with a tone that's trying to score points rather than genuinely engage with the nuances of trauma research. This is 100% an ego -flex, nothing more.
Happy that the writer doesn't have any patterns that he's struggling with that stem from childhood. Good for him. But please don't project your 'perfect mental health' and lack of any trauma imprints on everyone else still struggling into adulthood with patterns of flight, fright and fawn, that altlhough we're conscious of, we struggle to overcome.
I’m not disagreeing with anything in your article nor the science presented. I think it’s good to be skeptical, ask questions, and decide what’s true/untrue/exaggerated/unsubstantiated/outright lies/etc.
Just wanted to add, from personal experience, my body definitely kept the score when I failed to grieve the death of my infant son in 2003. I tried to avoid grief for 20 years and my body did not go along with that plan. I had several physical issues that surfaced and after I worked through my grief, those issues resolved.
I agree to both points here - I think it’s important to be skeptical of scientific studies, particularly in a field such as psychology which has numerous well-known issues with reliable results. However, I feel that it’s wiser to say that the science is not definitive one way or another rather than insisting there’s no merit to the book at all.
Well, okay. But the issue here is not that "science" is making dubious or untenable claims. Rather, it is that van der Kolk himself is citing scientific studies to back up his claims that don't actually back up his claims.
not everything in life should be science. your experience is lived and intuitively you felt in your body that the traumatic event challenged you for so long. people who only believe in science or intuition are extremists and don't understand that life is infinitely nuanced. your experience is valid and you are brave for sharing it.
Thank you Vereya. I agree science isn't everything, especially when we're talking about grief. Sure there can be scientific studies about grief and how people experience it but science will have a hard time putting parameters on grief. As you said, it's infinitely nuanced. Love that.
Sure, nuance is absolutely needed, but so is truth. If a theory has limited basis in objective reality, then how well is it really going to help people?
Very sorry for your loss. I heard it phrased once that the brain keeps the score and the body is the scoreboard. Your experience makes sense, and with many others like it, it makes sense that VDK would be as popular as he is. He clearly tapped into something important that needed to be addressed. But he may have done that while still being wrong about some important things.
Thank you Owen. I agree VDK tapped into something important but that doesn't mean he's right about everything.
"He clearly tapped into something important that needed to be addressed."
Yeah, I have a bit of beef with the OP over this. The average person doesn't know an amygdala from an insula, and doesn't need to. The average person won't remember those kinds of details.
OP kinda... misses the point. Which probably also explains why OP thought the book would fade into obscurity: OP was focused on scientific details, so they didn't understand why the book was meaningful for people. OP is talking science, but the science is mostly not what's drawing people to the book.
So if you're going to argue with TBKTS, for most of us, it's more useful if you focus on the parts of the book that actually *impact* us. Takeaways for the average person:
- what counts as trauma? How endemic is it?
- the existence of the body-mind connection
- the way trauma can have long-lasting impacts on mental and emotional health
- how can we treat/resolve PTSD
Or, takeaways with *emotional* impact for the average reader:
- it's ok that that Bad Stuff that happened to you is still impacting you today
- you can heal, and you have some agency there; the power to direct your healing
- here are some ways to do so
Hi Jennifer. I am a certified Thanatologist and grief doula and have supported hundreds of bereaved through their grief journey. We know that grief is a physical, spiritual, emotional and social experience that also re-wires our brain. I was sad to hear about the death of your baby and wanted to acknowledge the courage and compassion it takes to process this giant loss. ❤️
Hi Dina. Thank you for your thoughtful feedback and encouragement. What a sacred job you do supporting people on their grief journeys. 💙
I know this also to be true from personal experience with grief.
You are opening up a hornets nest here, but you surface a real issue.
The reason the book is so resonant with people is the experience that unresolved pain does seem to “lodge itself” (specifically avoiding technical terms) in the body. Moreover, curiosity about the unconscious responses your body has to stimuli may be healthy and help resolve somatic issues.
Your article suggests that there may be an attribution issue, and I don’t quarrel with that.
The two issues as I see it:
1. The dominance of neuroscience right now is not fully earned. Much of the research that correlates lived experience with chemical pathways and neurological imaging is unsupportable hogwash, like understanding software design by x-raying a computer chip while it is running.
2. The book errs because it pretends it is not a psychology book and tries to be a neuroscience book. It would have been a better book simply if he had not tried to do that. As you astutely point out, the studies don’t really back up his assertions.
I'm sorry for your loss Jennifer. I had a similar experience. I tried to avoid grief after my 12 year old daughter died. It took 20 years to catch up to me also, and catch up to me it did. The trauma work of van der Kolk and Mate have helped me immensely along with the help of a compassionate trauma informed therapist.
Thank you Janalyn. I'm sorry for your loss as well. From a fellow avoider's perspective, it seems when grief catches up to you, it hits even harder because of all that pent up momentum. I'm so glad you found help, especially with a grief and trauma informed therapist. 💙
First, I am so sorry for the loss of your infant son. How tragic for you and your family. I cannot even properly imagine how you must have felt. You have my deepest sympathy. What I want to say is not to diminish your suffering, the psychological or physical suffering that has come from not processing your grief. But how do you know for sure that this is what caused your health issues? Your experience is anecdotal. What would prove your claim that they are connected is a research study that has been peer reviewed and given the nod for publication. Then, to further enhance its authority in this subject would be for someone to do the same type of study on the issue and come up with the same results. This is not to diminish your suffering and the psychological suffering that has come from not processing your grief.
I appreciate your interest and don’t take offense by your questions Kathie. But I have to disagree that you could do multiple research studies of people in grief and those studies would “come up with the same results” thus proving the way grief impacts people. Grief isn’t a math problem or something you can find an answer to like a riddle. Human beings are infinitely complex… and so is the way they love and the way they grieve.
Absolutely, people are very different. And no, it’s not about math, but most of what we know for sure about a myriad of human behaviour comes from qualitative research, looking for themes, gathering them together, looking for patterns etc. And yet still, they are generalizations, and some people just don’t fit in those patterns.
I think the author was not suggesting that the 'body doesn't keep the score'. But rather that van der Kolk failed to prove this, and more specifically he claimed trauma happened in every minor inconvenience. Which actually take away from experiences like yours here.
He is saying being a baby with an ambilical cord around your neck is the same as what you have experienced.
I also believe the author and the book he is citing is specifically claiming that van der Kolk's is commiting gross academic dishonesty. Because were these claims of his true he would've written a research article and let it be peer reviewed.
He did not, he published a book to the general public who does not know any better and that in a culture where victimhood is championed. Giving those 'victims' more reason to not take responsibility for themselves. He knows he would make money because of this - cause it sounds nice to be validated.
Yes, you make many very excellent points @Simoné Prinsloo.
Thank for adding these important observations to the discussion 🙏🤓
The claim that “only the outdated therapist uses CBT as their primary intervention”… I would like to see sources for that. Now, “first-wave CBT,” I would agree that few therapists still use those approaches. So much research is still being done on various versions of CBT and CBT-derived therapies (e.g., ACT, DBT, CPT, on and on), that I highly doubt this person’s claim
Knowledge is indeed power, and you don’t know me any better than I know you. I honestly wasn’t trying to insult you or your extensive experience with trauma.
I agree with you 100% that CBT is NOT a standalone treatment for PTSD. Never said it was. *I* don’t use it to treat PTSD; I obtained extensive training and supervision in other modalities. I simply argued against your statement that CBT is completely outmoded and therapists who use it are outdated. You did not specify “for PTSD.” It was a blanket statement.
CBT is certainly not the only tool in my therapeutic quiver—and it’s an important one, though again, as you more than rightfully point out, not for trauma in adults. And while CBT may be “easy to teach” (arguable, at least to teach well), it is far from easy to learn to do in a way that is personable and allows a therapist to really connect with a client and make a difference for them. In my opinion, therapists listing their “specialties” on Psychology Today list 10-20 therapy modalities is more “proof” that people think a two-day PESI course makes them qualified to list it as a modality they know and use well than evidence that CBT is outmoded. I personally don’t trust that a therapist who lists more than perhaps 5 modalities really knows them thoroughly and uses all of them competently. It’s incredibly difficult to know even that many well enough to use them regularly and competently.
Finally, having an undergraduate degree in molecular biology, a masters in science journalism, and over a decade as a well-respected science journalist under my belt, as well as a graduate degree in psychology, I’m probably more knowledgeable than most therapists I know about using http://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov and better equipped to read said papers with a critical eye. Published—and even peer-reviewed—hardly means without fault. Science itself is an iterative process, and what we thought we knew for sure today may be considered ridiculous in 10 years.
Sure, sure, but just because many therapists use purple-hat modalities like EMDR and IFS and hypnotherapy doesn’t mean they are actually backed up by good clinical research. Meta-analysis shows that all modalities of therapy work roughly equally well, and you can dismiss Can’t all you want, but it is the most robust of all modalities in terms of research.
There are many woo-woo therapists who offer hypnosis, past-life regression therapy, and other New Age nonsense, so it’s reasonable to be skeptical of the field when they continue to train therapists in modalities that really have no strong evidence base for them yet.
22 YEARS!! Doesn't that prove exactly how therapy doesn't work?
I'd say losing a child is 100% traumatic. Period.
I do know what you're saying and while that's all true I also feel that saying it to someone who is grieving the loss of a child (which is the ultimate loss and one I witnessed my parents experience when my brother died) isn't actually helpful. Obviously the word “trauma” gets thrown around a lot in the world we live in now and I think it can be a real disservice to people, but I think the opposite can also be true. Colonialism has polluted everything for sure. But here we are. And I think there is a time to say that your “trauma” is just internalized colonialism and a timely to not say it.
Good takedown of bad science of Trauma. But speaking from experience, trauma can cause chronic stress and mental disfunction. It can fuel feedback loops that make life incredibly hard and painful, which is stressful, which makes it worse. And prolonged chronic stress does cause terrible health problems.
Your point about some people being predisposed to trauma is very important. It's very unequal between people. But this supports the idea that more people have trauma than recognize it. We have a cultural idea of trauma (something horrific happened to you). But the cause of trauma is overwhelming negative feelings, which depend on how sensitive you are. A sensitive person, and children in general, are more easily traumatized. For example I read a story of someone traumatized because he was falsely blamed for something as a kid and his dad didn't believe him. He depended on his dad to protect him, so it felt like a deep betrayal to not be trusted when he was scared and upset and telling the truth.
The severity of trauma also depends deeply on what happens after the bad experience. If you return to wholeness and safety (acceptance, understanding, care), you can fully express the pain and let it pass. It will leave and imprint but rarely a crippling one. But if you don't have anyone you feel safe being vulnerable with, it's terrifying and overwhelming. That's why losing trust in your family is so dangerous. It can spiral into getting more traumatized. This kind of trauma can start with a small seed and get very bad. I speak from experience.
Trauma varies in severity, so depending on what bar you set, lots of people have trauma. I agree that the point of revealing that shouldn't be to get people to obsess over painful childhood experiences. It's to help people see the conditioning in their mind that keeps them afraid, disconnected. Those can be known as feelings in the body, no memories required. And connecting with those feelings, sharing them with others, helps bring people back to wholeness.
Is there a GOOD science of trauma? If so, please would you share any literature or papers you may have written or suggestions for further reading and research. Thank you.
I’m looking forward to the new book out in September, The Biology of Trauma by Dr Aimee Apigian
I'm not an expert in the science of how it works. Here's some works I like:
https://metanosis.substack.com/p/leaving-eden-why-does-it-hurt-so
https://tasshin.com/blog/the-bio-emotive-framework-an-escape-from-the-hell-of-unprocessed-emotions/
Bessel wrote over 150 peer reviewed papers. Judith Herman, also a good one, back in 1993. The theories are not new at all.
I know …I did much of their training. 🙏
Good question. It would have to begin with debunking the fallacy that trauma is a thing, which it is not. Trauma is a word we use for a context. Trauma cannot cause anything any more than crime or play can cause anything. And looking for the causes of a context like trauma is similarly futile. We're not going to make any headway until we address the logical typing error errors in the way trauma is discussed.
I was brought up in a horrific environment that left my siblings and me with an abundance of issues to resolve, but I was the one who ended up with clearly diagnosable complex PTSD (yes, I know that’s not in the DSM), but to the point of being predisposed, I’m also the one with an Enneagram 6 wing 5 personality type — I’m essentially a fear based over-thinker…. So was it my personality type that set me up to develop cPTSD, and might I have walked more easily out of the early years if I’d been, say, a type 9?
I very much agree that the severity of how we carry overwhelming events has much to do with how loved and safe we feel afterwards. If there’s no one to go to for comfort, shelter, and guidance, the fear and mistrust are carried forward — as trauma…
If you haven't looked into Pete Walker's CPTSD: from surviving to thriving yet, I think you might find it very validating. He's also a type 6.
Thank you -- I did read it a few years ago, and it was supportive, but as I continue to heal, it might be good to read it again.
No worries. I've read it as part of a bookclub, and that's also very therapeutic.
Thank you for your very clear and elaborate comment, this was exactly what i was thinking but i could have never worded it this good ❤️
Some of the most traumatising experiences is growing up with neglect in all or some if its forms.
I was both ab*sed and neglected. I totally agree.
I’m puzzled how is that a reply to what I said? I’ve had none of those things. You will need to explain yourself
You are clearly into and attached to the trauma narrative. Your example of the boy and not being believed paints people as being so weak. Did the adult boy truly believe that he was beyond question or that he did not lie sometimes. Whenever I hear stories like this I think what’s this scmuck trying to cover up while seeking solace in “daddy didn’t believe me”.
But then I come from a world best capture by this expression - “if you see a boy hit him, because if he hasn’t done anything wrong, he’s about to”
Trauma my arse
I'll respond with the hope that you are actually curious, and not just here to dismiss others perspectives. I agree that attachment to trauma narratives is dangerous. I have struggled with it. What makes it dangerous is the victimization, the blame of the other and helplessness of the self. I was really emotionally fucked up by the consequences of my trauma (because I neglected myself). I really wanted to blame someone and insist it shouldn't have happened. But I eventually realized that what happened to me wasn't so bad, and it turned out so terribly because my reaction impaired the healing process. I was a kid, I didn't know what I was doing of course. The point is that trauma doesn't have to be someone's fault. And yet it exists and is worth understanding. It's hard to do that without a story of what happened. I agree that people aren't so weak that any bad experience traumatizes them. Nor are people so innocent that they won't blame others for the consequences of their own actions, and forfeit their agency in the process. But people have moments of weakness, of raw painful fear and distress. And in those moments, it's very important to receive care and understanding from the people you are close to. I can't speak for the boy because I don't know him, only that story. But even if he were a liar sometimes, he could still have been hurt by being untrusted in his moment of vulnerability. You are right to say that all people do wrong. We all have the potential and the tendency for evil. We all engage in conflict and hurt each other. And sometimes that creates trauma. It's all perfectly natural and not anyone's fault. So I'm not saying parents can raise healthy children with no trauma by being 100% nice and trusting all the time. They will get taken advantage of. It is wise and important to engage in conflict with their children. To use power over them, even when they find it scary and painful. But being aware of how trauma works helps you to prevent and heal it when it does happen. Subtle differences in attitude can make a big difference in regards to preventing trauma. For example really listening to kids and trying to understand their feelings and perspective (instead of being dismissive) helps. Fostering trust, care, and understanding helps, even if its always imperfect. It's worth trying to heal, trying to take care of each other. I hope you realize you don't have to choose between being naive and being an asshole
Yes I agree with everything you have said. However the trauma narrative and assumption is really unhelpful and lends itself to that ever present tendency in human towards deceit. Particularly of ourselves. But in every other way I agree with you.
For years, the “trauma narrative” gave me a reason for not fully engaging in a life that frightened me, but it also protected me until I was ready to. I was a victim because overt abuse (physical, emotional and sexual) at the hands of my parents had done huge damage to my ability to trust both the world around me and even myself. As I slowly began to understand how it had all altered my thoughts, feelings, and behavior, I was slowly able to place the harms in my past, understanding that I am most likely safe now, and that what happened was truly not my fault. I began to understand that I had both the power and the ability to live a life that was not based on fear. A huge turning point in my healing came when I realized that without the trauma, I felt empty, vulnerable, and feared that I was losing my identity. I’m still in the process of allowing all that to exist while slowly taking steps to trust and believe in the parts of myself that carried me out of the trauma situation at age 15, toward what I've made into a good life. I am so much more than my trauma, but was unable to understand that while in a vulnerable victim role. I’m learning now to honor myself as a survivor.
An aside: It feels to me that Tom Carson’s remarks here are about small t traumas, not the huge ones that make even sleep dangerous throughout one’s childhood.
And yet here you are, a living example of how being exposed to negative things like violence, neglect, disregard and dislike usually means people end up disliking themselves and disliking others. They also usually engage in violence, neglect, disregard and dislike. Monkey see, monkey do. Hope you've been shown some kindness and love in your life. Being horrid because "I had a hard time so everyone deserves a hard time" is such an exhausting and lonely place to be.
This is neither good science, nor good journalism
It reads simply as an attention seeking piece.
Get a job
What makes it bad science of trauma?
At the heart of it is shame, it's emotional flashbacks and 4F responses.
So beautifully said
Well said
I feel like this article misses the whole point of the book.
https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/if-its-worth-your-time-to-lie-its
If it was worth van de Kolk's time to write a book full of scientific half-truths and outright lies, it's worth Everett's time to write about those issues. The book would not have been half as persuasive if it didn't have all those "sources" that didn't match the studies.
That has basically nothing to do with the truth or falsity of his theory! You could write a book about how the moon landing was real with a ton of terrible scientific evidence and people would critique it.
That may be... critique is important. So is lived experience.
Beth, do you understand the concept of lived experience? It is the opposite of science. The whole point of science is to figure out ideas that can be replicated and negated, and that comes from seeking the objective. Just because the ideal objective is not attainable doesn't mean that's not the goal. When you use the phrase lived experience, what you're doing is telling the world that you have absolutely no idea how to formulate ideas that stand up to testing. Without the ability to test, we have no capacity to differentiate between physical evidence and dillusion.
Some things can't be tested - only felt.
LMAO the same people who were condemning others for not taking the experimental jabs because "much science" are now attacking the author of this post because, despite him quoting ACTUAL scientific literature, it doesn't fit with their "lives experience". And, just like he said, it's all females and people with low testosterone. How interesting...
I dunno, I think it’s pretty important to call out when popular science/psychology books are totally misrepresenting the studies they are citing even if there are ideas in the work that have merit
This may or may not be true but can you elaborate? Just saying that with no elaboration doesn’t help those of us trying to make sense of this lol
First, a little context, I am trauma survivor and a trauma-informed care trainer. I read this book slowly and cross-referenced with many other concepts and trauma theories, and have discussed its contents extensively with therapists, educators, and survivors. I never got the sense that Bessel was attempting to portray himself or his work as being the gold standard of anything. But rather he was sharing his perspective on his life's work. As someone who felt like they had already healed their childhood trauma wounds prior to reading this book, I found my healing was able to deepen through reflecting upon the case studies shared and resonating with many of the stories of embodied practices, creating transformational healing experiences. It's one book on my Trauma informed care bookshelf. It's one book in an epic list of resources that we have access to. I think if you read the book with criticality in mind, you will take something away from it that is positive. I do appreciate his definition of trauma, which is the definition that I would begin every single trauma-informed care training with "traumatization occurs when both internal and external resources are inadequate to cope with an external threat."
Then we would unpack that definition. What is an internal resource? What is an external resource? How are those resources? Adaptive or maladaptive? Essentially, everyone is unique and we are shaped by our experiences and our conditioning to be more or less likely to be traumatized by a given external threat.
I missed this answer to my question when you first wrote it. Thank you. Very
clarifying. 🙏
Differentiation of therapeutic modalities is essential. That is my key take away from Van Der Kolk's work. Everyone has a unique context and thus will need individualized trauma responsive care. CBT is great for some, EMDR is great for some, other cultural practices are effective too. Turf wars are unnecessary in the healing realm. And yet it occurs because humans have capacity for criticality. And that is what it is.
Thank you. 100%.
Thank you.
In fact, I highly doubt whether the article writer ever read the book, based on all the nonsense he says about it.
The book is based on decades of research and many, many studies. Just because a few people like "Dave" misinterpreted it doesn't make it invalid.
LMAO he literally did a deep dive on the book and checked references. But don't let reality get in the way of your "trauma" little snowflake...
He says he did that--but his post doesn't sound like it.
Have you read the book? I have.
And I'm not a survivor of trauma, thankfully, but it's interesting that you automatically assumed I was, rather than just someone with expertise on the subject matter
What do you mean 'disingenuous'? The point was never that Bessel's work didn't have any merit but that the evidence he used to demonstrate whatever merit it may have had was rooted in outright falsehoods and representations. It's not about 'judging.' I've had severe PTSD, and so has my mother. I know the experience intimately. But I'd rather someone told me the truth about what I was experiencing and why, rather than spin shoddy logic to capitalize on my emotional readiness to make sense of my experience. You can absolutely write about trauma without lying. It feels utterly bizarre that you don't care that a book that's being read by thousands of people is filled with such falsehoods.
Ok... and?
Maybe it is bunk. But a lot of people feel a lot better walking around in their own skin because of Van Der Koek and Mate.
There is a lived reality of those of us who have high ACEs scores and are trying to break cycles.
Their books are tools that help. And that is okay.
Is it possible that there are also people who feel _worse_ walking around in their own skin after being told that what they thought were just bad childhood experiences - or experiences they didn't remember at all - were actually *traumas* that have permanently altered their brains? I try to err on the side of "If it worked for you, it's not fake to you"; frankly, I'm willing to believe that even the most obvious BS *can* work in very specific circumstances. For instance, I know a woman who, as she tells it, kicked a heroin addiction using "bionetics" and (I might be misremembering this part) some sort of biofeedback/bioresonance emulator device. Am I going to undermine her progress by explaining that the "science" she's relying on is all fake, that there were other factors that helped her, that at best the machine was simply the object of projection/disavowal of her own internal power to kick the addiction? Of course not. Who knows, maybe the device really did do what it said it'd do, but as far as I could tell, there was no evidence that it did so *reliably*, for a wide range of people in a wide range of circumstances. It seems like the same thing may be happening here: This theory of trauma may have worked wonders for you and some other people - and is true in that sense - but it doesn't look like there's enough reliable evidence that it would do so for anyone else, as opposed to better-studied approaches.
From what I've learned in my own journey, trauma doesn't have to PERMANENTLY change the brain. Neuroplasticity shows that it is possible to retrain your brain, and it has also been shown that some cells can be regenerated through neurogenesis - specifically the ones in the hippocampus, which is where a lot of damage is done when you've lived through repeated trauma. Trauma is an injury, and eventually injuries can be healed - or at least get somewhat better. It's just a LOT of hard work.
True. And (not but) those who feel better disseminate the information as if it’s provable and scientifically verified. And even talk about as such. Which very much sacrifices
truth and facts on the altar of feeling better. 😬
As a rape survivor, and someone who has worked with abuse survivors for almost 20 years, 100% agree with you, Michele.
I posted a response with 5 peer reviewed papers and my own lived experience that refuted his argument and the author removed my note. I'm not convinced this "person" isn't AI.
LMAO it's the old "feelings don't care about facts". No wonder we live in such a post truth dystopia. It's no longer about what is true and logic. Only about "feelings". Such are the ways of the gynocracy...
I think ilthe book can be all those things but inaccurate and misleading citation is never good and should be owned.
THANK YOU because you said it way better than me.
The perspective put forward in the piece is wholly gatekeeping and narrow. Unhelpful and likely harmful
If CBT was the whole answer... it would have worked by now.
🙏🙏 thank you for your incisiveness, Anna. i won’t even bother reading the essay. 🖤
I found CBT extremely traumatizing. I already had trouble labeling my feelings and thoughts, and CBT taught me to doubt myself even more. DBT, EMDR, trauma-informed therapy and somatic work are much better approaches IMHO.
Thank you for saying this. the whole point of science, bringing science and spirituality or the unseen together, is to put work out there and keep it evolving. It’s a mere idea that things build off of things- it’s the nature of our world. To critic so harshly is to throw the baby out with the bath water. This whole development in understanding trauma in the scientific world is emerging into general consciousness, not everyone is going to get it right the first time.
This trend to “discredit” Maté and van der Kolk is something we should be wary of—and highly cautious with. My problem with this take down of the ostensible “bad science” is that the writer ends with recommending … Alfred Adler of all people. One of the most discredited pseudoscientists in the entire field. There’s so much to tackle in this grift.
We have over 40 years of quality, cutting-edge neuroscience research—rigorous, peer-reviewed studies, hefty meta-analysis, and data from technological advances in neuroimaging—showing that the relational stimuli during the first three years of rapid neural migration, maturation, synaptogenesis, pruning, and myelin formation, absolutely impacts the wiring of our limbic structures (yes, the amygdala and insula, but also the hippocampus and hypothalamus). Neuroplasticity is also more pliable during adolescence and matrescence and patrescence. What happens to us in these years affects the brain as well as genetic expression. This is basic neuroscience. It’s not just Maté and van der Kolk.
This is shown in the academic literature out of Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child, Yale University’s Child Study Center, the University of Toronto’s SickKids’ Infant and Early Mental Health Promotion—and a litany of other prolific research centres.
To claim that since one can’t remember an event, it therefore has no effect on the developing brain is the height of scientific ignorance. Unfortunately many many folks before this writer have also used this vein of Tony Robbins self-improvement gospel to gain a following themselves. And despite the data, these people will always exist.
We can not deny that maternal sensitivity wires limbic structures in a healthy way, and causes epigenetic changes. An infant (0-3 in neuroscience) can not “self soothe” in the way the outdated behaviourists reprimanded parents with for decades. Infants breathe better, sleep better, and pump blood better when they are held. Skin-to-skin contact is well researched. Do adults remember this? No. Does it affect how their brains wire? Yes.
There is SO. MUCH. RESEARCH. on this. I have a list of citations on the above—none of which include Maté or Kolk. These are real scientists doing the lab work that science communicators cite. Personal experience, narrative, or bias should not discredit the rigorous work of these researchers—who do not have the time to educate the public on their findings.
Too many parents treat their babies, infants, and young children poorly because they “won’t remember” and this trend to tear down the advances we have made for children are deeply dismaying.
A collection of academic sources that isn’t cleaned-up, but which continues to grow each day neuroendocrinologists, neuroscientists, etc. publish their findings: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1j3KfTNzj6lIFe16VDJNYg-dHAxk2bg15sZdBCPI8Rv8/edit?tab=t.0
This is an excellent comment and much appreciated-I totally agree with you. Thanks also for posting the resources.
Thank you! I appreciate that
Thank you.., my god, as a PTSD specialist- I just didn’t even know where to begin with this post- and then the Adler comment? Spare me. Thank you for writing all this for me and saving me the energy. Th
I appreciate that Alison. It’s truly baffling (and exhausting!) given how much neuroscience and neuroendocrinology support critical-period closure. Pretty wild stuff. The most disappointing is that I stumbled upon this piece because a USC infant hormone researcher (and prolific “parenting” Substacker) shared it, leading my brain to explode with fury.
Thanks for this comment and resources
Thank you!
Why is Alfred Adler considered a pseudoscientist? I tried looking him up online and no mention of that. Only about his work in individual psychology and feelings of belonging and that his theories were different than Freud.
What's your take on Bruer's work, who basically refutes all of this evidence?
https://blogs.kent.ac.uk/parentingculturestudies/files/2011/09/Special-briefing-on-The-Myth.pdf
Hi May! Just saw this now, apologies. I’m very familiar with Bruer’s critique. There are areas I agree, but his work is mostly saturated with willfull blindness. I look at this more as an academic squabble and field confirmation bias: you see what you’re looking for. And Bruer looks over tens of RCT studies, neuroimaging data, and rigorous, quality peer-reviewed research in favor of complimentary—not contradictory as he finds it—findings. For starters, the neuroscience he’s looking at has much more to do with cognition and memory. IQ essentially. Most of the research supports that IQ is largely genetic. Playing Mozart in infancy won’t alter it. He’s correct there. Learning, additionally, is akin to a process called “conditioning” in the cognitive sciences. The premise is that repetition of the same thought/act reinforces the involved neurons to “fire and wire” together in response to specific stimuli. Synaptic and myelin formation happens across time and habituation. So yes, memory and learning are both a life-long process marrying stimuli, response and repetition. “What fires together wires together, and what don’t won’t” is how famed neuroscientist Carla Shatz summed up Donald Hebb’s theory and research. This is what Bruer’s critique tackles. The brain—from infancy into adulthood—is “plastic” and so responds appropriately to changing environmental and relational stimuli. He’s not wrong there either.
Where he IS wrong is in saying that the relational experiences/stimuli during the 0-3 years don’t lay the foundation for all of the above to happen. The brain is built similar to a house where the foundation matters for the stability of the upper structures. And that foundation—the brain stem and the limbic structures such as the amygdala and insula—are largely wired/closed around age 3. The neocortex (including the prefrontal cortex which is responsible for longterm planning, consequence weighing, and impulse control) are still being fired and wired until around age 25. It’s the area we see most neuroplasticity. BUT the early architecture of the limbic areas have more rapid neuron formation (and are more or less set for life) during the first three years.
Why this matters is because these structures are where our emotions, hormones, neuropeptides begin/have the most activity. If an early environment is chaotic, unpredictable, neglectful, abusive, or lacking in vital “serve and return interactions” of a parent warmly responding to a baby’s coos and cries, the limbic structures experience more stress (the cortisol cascade becomes more easily triggered) and less oxytocin (the hormone responsible for being “soothed”). That stress impacts all the above brain building processes. The brain may fire and wire neurons to be hyper reactive to stressors even when they aren’t present. This is well documented and well researched. A Greenberg lab (Harvard) paper, recently published in Nature, discusses this critical-period closure, noting, “In the months or years after birth, critical periods of learning in the brain are open, making the organ uniquely sensitive to information coming from the outside world. Experiences during this time have a lasting impact on the brain by sculpting neural connections that persist into adulthood. As a child or young animal matures, this heightened period of brain plasticity ends, as critical periods begin to close.” Bruer skips over all this work in favor of placing emphasis on the neuroplasticity of the neocortex.
When you see a critique of an expert or scientific consensus, it’s best to think of it as a school of fish. If most of the research points in one direction, and one paper darts off, you’re better suited to look at the bulk of conclusions over an offshoot one.
Here, you have one person saying “Hey the brain shows neuroplasticity into adulthood—so early experiences can be over-ridden!” while ignoring critical-period closure. The brain is a complex organ that forms in bursts, with specific ages being more susceptible to external inputs.
We can’t change how long our bones grow once we reach the height we’ll be as adults. But we can change or affect the tissue, muscle, weight that forms on top of those bones. Similar to this, we can’t nudge (far enough to be efficient) the limbic structures reactivity, or how they “fire and wire” in response to stressors (and the autonomic hormone response that happens within milliseconds of sensing a stressor). But we can change how we *think* about and act towards those stressors—through meditation, EMDR, somatic experiences, etc—as the neocortex, where these functions take place, is more plastic.
These choices and considered actions can help make our nervous systems a little bit more, or a little bit less, reactive. But they can’t change fundamentally to the core, as that foundation was laid in our first few years, including in the prenatal months. This is what Bruer misses with his overemphasis on neuroplasticity and underemphasis of critical-period closure.
I was supposed to read this book for my "trauma informed" classes. I quit reading the book after the first 10 pages. (while I'm required to do a certain amount of trauma informed training, I find most authors and instructors have never faced trauma themselves a day in their life and so have no clue what they're talking about.)
90% of psychology/sociology is complete BS and studies can't be replicated, because each human perceives things so differently. Get 10 witnesses to any situation and you'll get ten different POVs about that incident. Some will have a "fight or flight" response (could lead to 'trauma') and some could see it as no big deal.
I'm not saying trauma DOESN'T exist. It does. Falling off your bike and breaking your arm might have been the 'worst thing to ever happen to you, and thus was 'traumatic.' But acting like the body isn't an amazing organism designed to heal (mentally, spiritually, and physically) from such events is where psychology fails. We are resilient creatures. (Until we have that resilience trained out of us through learned-helplessness.)
If any of these yahoos actually CARED about "healing your trauma" (rather than selling books and making $$$), they would talk about how the news media, 24/7 TV, digital devices, etc. actually train us to operate out of sympathetic nervous system (Fight or Flight) rather than existing within our parasympathetic nervous system, which is where all our daily functions (eating, sex, sleep, etc) are controlled. And THAT'S where Alternative and Complementary Medicines (Healing Touch, Meditation, chiropractor, etc.) can have a huge impact, because it reminds your body what it feels like to NOT be in "fight or flight" mode. (None of those modalities are cures for anything, by the way. They just help your body return to its natural state, then the body - not being controlled by 'fight or flight' is much more likely to take care of itself, as it was designed.)
Oh man I felt the same way. I actually purchased it from Amazon, skimmed it and returned it after I realized there was not a single important thing in the book. Do yoga, spend time in nature, keep a regular sleep schedule, maintain friendships. No shit? That stuff is necessary whether you have trauma or not. It doesn’t do a single thing for those with severe trauma and PTSD.
Agape …interesting choice of name and meaning thereof.. Hope you have some success with your project…good to have a variety of viewpoints on the vast topic of Jesus …..in the meantime, you have important things to do by the sound of it .and we all know that Life is a Lifelong Pursuit. Good wishes.
Thank you! 🙏
What is the title of your book? I presume you have one or it’s in the ‘pipeline’ ?
It’s been in the pipeline for about 20 years. 🤣. It’s gone through about 5 iterations. The current one is “Life in the Gaps: a journey through the Paschal Triduum.”
But I highly doubt I’ll ever publish, so I write on Substack and serve as a Spiritual Director and Healing Touch Practitioner.
All of this. Yes. 💯.
Gabor Mate does address the impacts of modern technology, the tv hr news, digital divices on stress to some extent in the myth of normal, and he recommends another book, i-minds, that goes into much more detail on the issues.
Thank you. Goodbye.
Interesting perspective. Thank you for sharing! I'm a holistic nutritionist and am finding nervous system work to be the most important foundational work for a plethora of things.
This didn't post my reply to the right thread for some reason - sorry about that!
I’m a healing touch practitioner. But I’ve actually studied more of the sciences and psychology because of my spiritual direction work. In today's society most of the problems I encounter (Mental, Spiritual and even some physical) are due to nervous system issues.
Note my words ‘something else’ and ‘researched the subject further’ ….it’s quite easy to misinterpret or misunderstand someone else’s opinions. Time to disengage from this thread for once and for all.
It does….and until someone on here or elsewhere writes something else having researched the subject
further, I guess it’s good to have some insight into trauma thinking and understanding….thus far. It’s also good for us all to cultivate empathy and compassion ….in any case!!
If you mean research about the nervous system, a lot of that does exist - which is what makes some of this 'trauma informed' psychobabble frustrating. If you mean in regards to specific Complementary Medicine Modalities, you need to look at the research available within each specific area, since getting grants to have research posted on sites like the NIH are few and far between. (But you can still find some posted there.)
I'm sorry you have experienced all of those things. You are right, it is very complex. And"Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs" absolutely needs to be considered. I'm sorry if by not mentioning basic needs being met left you with the impression that I didn't think those were important.
However, it is never either/or; it is always both/and. For example: if you are only ever operating out of your sympathetic nervous system (fight/flight), then your awareness of your Hierarchy of Needs actually shift, because all of those needs are controlled by your parasympathetic nervous system. Why would you care about eating, when you're constantly worrying about needing to run away and hide? Or fight to the death - If you're going to die, you have no need of food.
Yes, the government systems (across most countries) leave a great deal to be desired when it comes to anything that's not Western Medicine or involves Mental Health. And honestly most books like this one (and don't get me started on all the 'self help' books!) actually do more harm than good for those who try to encourage the governments to change how those services are used.
Yes, his trauma of being addicted to buying CDs. I (I'm an recovered alcoholic, from a family of alcoholics (it wasn't pretty) and I work in addiction support) found it really difficult to take that at face value, I mean I understand that any process can be an addiction but I had to put the book down for a while to process that. I am aware of his history and I'm not referring to that.
I think Diana was talking about the holocaust childhood stuff.
Perhaps, you didn't read all of this article, or the articles linked within it. There are other issues with Gabor Mate's works. I've attended several seminars that featured him. Given the hype about him I received leading up to the first one I attended, I was less than impressed. Maybe his earlier works were better. But this was back in late 2019. (Pre-COVID)
This honestly explains some of the nonsense that I see coming out of pop psychology and TikTok self-diagnoses. I was wondering why the word "trauma" was appearing everywhere in discussions of psychology for the past few years.
To be fair, a good majority of people have trauma, especially with boomers as our parents. Read the book “the myth of normal” by Gabor mate.
right, and don’t forget the christians and mormons and jahova witnesses and i could go on and on. all teaching to whip and beat and subdue their children, to be willing to walk their children up to the point of death in the name of some higher being. that taught their children they were sinful and deserving of hell, being exposed to some real fucked up shit (drink this pretend it’s blood), purity/rape culture.
religion is STILL RUNNING THINGS, and dividing whole nations, while causing countless wars and death. all being weaponized for power within government.
yeah there’s a shit ton of trauma. if you didn’t experience it, consider yourself lucky!
You said it!
Social media likes to promote the idea that everyone has PTSD! It's not true"
Valid point. But I think it's fair to say that a larger-than-expected number of people have relational issues or maladaptive coping mechanisms that are partially caused by past trauma. Not quite so far as "everyone has PTSD", and more "most people have lingering problems caused by past trauma".
This. There’s such a big difference between childhood trauma and trauma experienced as an adult. Trauma doesn’t need to “re-wire” a child’s brain because it effects the original wiring as it’s created. Kids’ nurture experiences determine things like gene expression, so no surprise trauma at that age could affect the body.
thank you so much for this piece — i found it a refreshing perspective. one part that stood out was the mention of dave asprey attributing his ptsd to birth trauma.
i’ve given birth twice in the last four years, & as part of that, i’ve spent a lot of time learning about birth physiology. a nuchal cord is fairly common, occurring in around 20–30% of all births. in most cases, it’s not harmful. babies aren’t breathing air yet; they’re still receiving oxygen via the placenta, so unless the cord is tightly compressed (rare), there’s no danger. in most cases, it’s simply looped off by the birth worker during delivery.
what struck me is how something so normal can, over time, be reinterpreted as traumatic — especially through the lens of books or frameworks that suggest trauma lives in the body, even if we don’t remember it. i say this as someone who carries very real trauma. the more i’ve reflected on my past, the more i’ve come to believe in the chicken-and-egg theory. the more you look for trauma, the more you find it — sometimes even in places it may not really exist. i’ve noticed how easy it is, when processing old experiences, to reshape them into something they maybe never were. it’s a strange thing — trying to honour your pain while also being honest about what really happened.
i’m so grateful for writing like this that invites nuance, curiosity, & a bit more grounded thinking — especially in such a tender, often polarised, space.
Psychology is pseudoscience. This is why 70% of social science studies cannot be replicated. The reason being is that we are all very different. Each group that you study is going to give different results. Plus the person performing the research is fallible, may already have a result they want to achieve in mind, and their funding may hinge on getting that result.
But that's not a reason to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
And you're right, trauma alone doesn't cause mental illness. But its not just genetics either. Its both.
Also, PTSD, like all mental illness, festers in isolation. When we have communities to help us process traumatic events, theyre less likely to linger, but we live in a very isolating world today.
There are so many psych treatments and medications because we are all so nuanced that its like throwing darts at a board. Bessel dismisses CBT in The Body Keeps the Score, but it works very well for many people.
Also, he tells an anecdote of EMDR completely eradicating PTSD symptoms in a woman. EMDR doesn't work for everyone, and its just a half assed version of clinical hypnosis.
Exercise, go outside, eat clean, healthy relationships, and community do more for mental health than anything.
Every person I've ever known who is struggling isolated themselves. Get out of your own head. The world wants you to come kick it with us.
That said, some people are simply born with broken brains and absolutely need psych meds.
But the vast majority are suffering the consequences of a screwed up culture consumed by consumption. Its difficult to eat clean when everyone around you does not care. Moms do not give a shit about your diet. No choice but to refuse food and suffer the social consequences.
So many people are never outside, or believe that its going to make their face rot off. Sun exposure provides endogenous opioids. Endorphins.
The good news is that its a great time to be alive for the disciplined.
As a mental health therapist who has treated people for years, Trauma is real and healing one’s trauma does not go away with diet and exercise.
While I see my clients improve dramatically in their thinking, Behaviors, relationships, parenting and quality of life from
Therapy, people tend to then have the want and energy to lead healthier lifestyles.
The patriarchal myth that the need for therapy is just about Character flaws(pull up your bootstrap mentality pushed by our maga folk who claim. “I did it and I’m ok) is harmful to people suffering the effects of trauma and I would argue maga personalities tend to be sociopathic ( fear based, shame based, anger based and discrimination based) and extremely harmful to children and now the people of our country.
"Trauma is real and healing one’s trauma does not go away with diet and exercise."
Where was that claim articulated or implied in the article?
My takeaway from the article is that the book's author made a lot of very specific claims concerning trauma and the human body that aren't supported by the studies he cited. There have been many times when I found something useful and meaningful in a book or essay that turns out to contain some false or incorrect claims, or correct claims based on junk arguments, but that doesn't mean I don't appreciate it when those errors or misrepresentations are pointed out after the fact.
I was with you until you blamed it on patriarchy. Everything you hate is not automatically patriarchy. The institution of psychiatry was created by men in a patriarchal milieu.
I’m now confused because I like both of your comments 🤣
Its one of the problem
Just because patriarchy is one of society’s problems doesn’t mean we should lazily just use the term as a label for everything we don’t like. It just dilutes the meaning into nothingness. Patriarchy is a social system. It doesn’t just mean say macho or hypernasculine. Maybe extreme machoness and hypermasculinity is averse to therapy but the general system of patriarchy, which is rule by men for the primary benefit of men, supports therapy just fine.
Well said.
Yea it does. I've seen many such cases. The matriarchal myth that everyone is broken and needs therapy and infinite medications is just detrimental to ACTUAL human well being.
Someone told me once that psychology should be considered a liberal art and not a hard science and I must say I tend to agree … there are far too many unmeasurable and unseen external factors to be able to measure them with anywhere near the accuracy of other hard sciences
Edit: psychology IS a liberal art, but we have trouble still wanting it to have hard-sciences like easily replicable data .. sorry for wording that poorly
Which is why it is called a social science. Psychology is most certainly not an art - wherein postmodern notions of 'whatever you feel/all opinions are equal' apply. This is why, though most Universities have psychology depts, none label it as an arts subject. Psychology is the ongoing quest to discover reliable truths about the mind and brain - an organ which is the most mysterious and complicated thing we humans have ever come across, and which isobcviously roooted in objective phenomena. No surpise that the tools of science are not sufficiently developed to bring the surity you demand (really, what were you thinking; that the truths of the mind & brain should be easy to find?). The young field of psychology has come along leaps and bounds in recent years, and is slowly but surely meeting the crisis of replication etc.
By the way, Neither Gabor Mate nor Bessel Van der Kolk are psychologists - they are psychiatrists, medical Drs; and there is long history of these high status amateurs bungling into the field of psychology without good training. Starting with Freud.
Just so you’re aware- Social sciences fall under the umbrella of liberal arts…
my point is to distinguish it from the hard sciences- many seem to want the kind of hard data and precision sciences like physics and chemistry can achieve with psychology and thats just never going to happen. And many psychiatrists essentially operate as therapists and counselors within their profession as Mate and van der Kolk have clearly done . There’s a lot of crossover within mental health professions.
Indeed - in the US - though in the UK it's a 'Humanities' subject. No biggie, although I can't see how either term, art or liberal, fits psychology. In both countries psy is a social science - I think you'd agree that those protesting the label of the 'S word, simply don't understand what Science is (BTW: I meant to reply to Kezia Vida/jon Raiser rather than you!) One of the first things I was taught in science class (aged 9) was that everything we would be taught was at least a little wrong - the process of science being what it is will lead to ever more accurate ideas that replace the older. If we followed 'Occam's Raiser' no science would have ever got off the ground, as all initial thereories were risible and unreplicated.
I understand the crossover between the fields - my frustrated point is i) that many people dismiss psychology on the basis of dodgy psychological claims of people.... who are not actually psychologists; and ii) who lack a modern psychological education, are not well grounded in research methodology (as I suspect you know already, current psychology research methods are actually particularly good, and getting better, at applying scientific principles to humanities phenomena (the field has taken the replication crisis seriously, and learnt from it).
'Whatever you feel/all opinions are equal.' Haha, as someone who's been to Art school, it's far more critical than that!
We are far too nuanced for it to ever be a hard science.
Evolution can’t be easily replicated either. I never get this argument for proving why some knowledge is useless. The scientific method isn’t the be all end all for knowledge being useful or worthwhile.
Absolutely.
There are no easy answers. Everyone is different. Everything is a tradeoff. Nothing is certain. But none of that is a reason to stop trying.
Unfortunately, many people either only read the first sentence of my comment, or don’t have the bandwidth to recognize nuance.
Excellent point “Also, PTSD, like all mental illness, festers in isolation. When we have communities to help us process traumatic events, theyre less likely to linger, but we live in a very isolating world today.” Most o the issues today are because of break down of the community
We begin as a fish. A parents’ nightmare or wish. Swimming within what feels an abyss. When our timeline is sparked, we ram. No more a fish, now we are pushed with a whoosh onto land. A baby. Still with no working legs to stand. We come forth as a lamb. Now we have landed upon Earth. What a birth! Have we been uniquely blessed or been cursed? Life might seem suspect and underhanded. Exactly where have we landed? Upon what sort of sordid planet? What of us is going to be required or demanded? Will we be strong like Bull? Or be seen as a cowardly calf with little to no soul. Just a joke and a laugh. Here to be someone else’s servant and staff. Either way we become split from the get go. Twins; one goes high and the other low. Both a Devil and an Angel speaking for the parts of our soul. While the body keeps score, No? Trying to discern what all we can know. Just how loud is our crow? When does the party start? When can we go? This confusion makes us emotionally crabby. Will we receive comfort or need to be grabby? My how our pinchers can be so sharp and stabby. Within us too is a tomcat; a tabby. Here comes our lion. An individual quest for our own truest Zion. An ego’s soul seeking the heavens. With a slot machine gamble. Big betting; lucky number sevens. Might cash in the cow. Eventually we’ll land on our ass with an ow. A clash of a titan without much class. Our feet will eventually need to touch grass. We shall sow the seeds for the harvest like a virgin. Still, the heart beats through this incursion. Focus upon health and work for discernment. Strike a balance between our many urges to ferment. Here the scales of justice enter into the equation. The power of self within a vast complex nation. So many disagreements between the generations. Pretty soon we require a respite, a soulful vacation. So we will slide into the depths of our sensations. Lurking with a scorpion’s prolonged patience. Contemplating the secrecy of sex and the death of relations. We might get lost here if we don’t change the station. So we’ll embark upon new situations. Allow our fires to spark! Hark, now we’re riding an arrow! Launched from the archer’s bow. Half human and half workhorse. Don’t you know? Oh how far we can travel and how much we can grow! And when we learn we can build! We can conquer and develop and drill. We can form formidable guilds. Banking the till. We don’t want God’s abundance spilled on those we’d much rather HE kill. We are mermaid tailed goats. We must be kings of the hills. Surrounding our castles with moats. Greatest of all time? Totes! Yet what’s up must one day come down. Before we go, take a good look around. We need to make our mermaid parts proud. And so, tumble bumble, we spill forth from this highflying crowd. Our splash might be quiet or loud. Once again we’ll need kin. A water bearer, releasing us into the quirky intelligence of our sin. A stop, drop, and roll and a renewal begins. We feel the spark! The ahh of our ark. Building technologies allowing all life to creatively embark. It’s the least we can do. For this melting pot stew. So we travel the spiral between losses and wins. Diving back into the oceans where we’re fish once again! Schooled this time, so now all of us win. The whole swath of us riding the waves of this most mystical spin.
psychologists think they know it all and treat you as if they are gods. and in reality, they are one of the most damaged people out there.
Psychology isn't a pseudoscience.
What psychology is, however, is a new science. And it is actually fairly common for studies to be hard to replicate in new sciences because the techniques are still being worked out by practitioners.
Your whole comment illustrates that you don't really understand scientific logic.
Google Freud and Jung's connections to mysticism. Psychology is mysticism repackaged for a materialist science world. It will never be a hard science because humans are far too complex. Well, it might become hard science after transhumanism happens.
Hot take! Get ready for wrath of the pearl clutching psychology worshipping church ladies.
I should preface this eith: Theres a lot of truth to psych. My body reacts to certain situations in wacky ways. I've read a ton of psych books the past few years and its helped me immensely. But it has a lot of pitfalls. Namely, those who use it as an excuse to never change. The ones who see it as religion. Who refuse post traumatic growth.
They've been here many times. None of them understands that "That doesnt mean that we should throw the baby out with the bathwater" means that psychology is still valuable. But its merely a tool to help understand yourself and everyone else, not a panacea, and not a religion. And none of them want to do difficult things or change to get better. Their psych religion gives them an excuse instead of pushing them to do better. All psych treatments from EMDR to SSRIs are like throwing darts at a board. The DSM started with 100 pages, is now over 1000, and has pathologized EVERYONE.
I just started bilateral stimulation a couple months ago and love it
Psychology is 100% pseudoscience
It's such a broad field, you have to make that statement much much more specific to be anything more than complete nonsense.
Like we have no idea what Adderall does to a brain? We have no idea what sleep is? Variable reinforcement learning? That's all pseudoscience?
It’s true it was a blase comment; but at the root the concept of psyche to me is immaterial and subjective at its core. So the idea that we can have a science of that, if you are a materialist, to me is an epistemological error. And of course western science, and western psychology, is dominated by a materialist epistemology. So yes we can have useful information from the framework of materialist science about those topics, but I don’t think it’s necessarily helpful, or really even capable of, answering fundamental questions of the psyche; ie why are we here? Who am I? How do I alleviate my suffering?
That’s why I call it pseudo science, it pretends to be able to answer questions that it can not. These are questions that do not have materialist science answers. The evidence of this is manifest in the reality of the failure of psychology and psychiatry to achieve mental wellness in the westernized population, and in fact the marked decline in wellbeing experienced after the rise of these “sciences”.
I do not ascribe any moral failing to deeply concerned and hardworking individuals who devote themselves to these paradigms, and to anyone who has a sincere desire to use that energy in a way that tries to meet the need for psychological healing in our world. I deeply believe that humans are for the most part doing their best with the hand they were dealt. But psychologists need to understand that the popularity and deep resonance among people of the body meets the score is evidence enough of its impact and psychological reality. We don’t need neurological evidence to “prove” something that so many people are experiencing and telling us they are experiencing.
No it’s not that. MRIs are a key diagnostic tool for neuropsychological research. What do they demonstrate, really? Namely, where blood is flowing or not in the brain. What does that mean? Reading How Emotions Are Made is helpful in this. I am not saying there is never anything useful found from the experiments, but at the core the questions of psychology are not scientific questions, or rather can not be answered by materialist science. For example, what can we point to in the physiology that shows someone has bipolar disorder? No answer currently, no test. Also, what is the psyche, how is it scientifically defined? What is an emotion, how do you measure it? What is happiness? To me the biggest demonstration that psychology is pseudoscience is how deeply terrible our psychological treatments are. If a cancer doctor had the same treatment success rate as psychiatrists have at curing the “diseases” they say they are curing, the cancer doctor would be put on trial for malpractice. Why is it different? We seem to want the rigor of science to put a rubber stamp on things but at the same time we allow for the “science” of psychological treatment to fail miserably, seemingly admitting to ourselves that the science isn’t the whole story, yet we cling to it. I’m sorry but look deeper at tools like brain scans, and at the science of things like emotions. It’s truly not nearly as rigorous as you might imagine.
Neuropsychology is a different animal than 'psychology'
would it be bad to be so? why is science end all be all anyway? do we function based on science most of the time? do you push the door harder when it's heavier because you know the physics behind it or because you naturally sensed to do so? intuition is not a stupid thing, it's the first thing leading to science and it's powerful
I appreciate that people like you think the way you do and go to such lengths to present your arguments- science and reason will ALWAYS be crucial to knowledge and progress.
I’ve never read the Body book, nor do I care for Mate, but I do and have undergone successful treatment for C-PTSD and was looking for you to mention Complex trauma above. You didn’t, which is fine, but demonstrates you’re just coming from a totally different experience and knowledge base than people who have (reportedly) related to and benefited from reading the Body book specifically.
I also looked for you to mention an absolutely excellent and reputable book, “The Practical Guide for Healing Developmental Trauma.” Heller (PhD) & Kammer (LMFT) and you also didn’t.
This book explains, discusses and instructs how to use neuro affective relational modeling for treating adverse childhood experiences ( which is how C PTSD develops). AKA the trauma you’re skeptical of.
Whether or not the Body book adequately references scientific evidence, trauma does, in fact, get stored in the brain and nervous system and manifests as C-PTSD.
In my opinion, you’ve chosen two weak (but admittedly popular) resources to attack, which again, is reasonable, but I simply don’t see the point in arguing against the experiences of so many who these sources have resonated with as helpful resources on their trauma healing journey.
Isn’t the real point to have a society of whole, happy people? And we are in the infancy of figuring out how to get there. It’s going to be imperfect and we need people like you to challenge our methods, but also, people like you to acknowledge (developmental) trauma exists and spend (more) time finding the reputable resources that adequately acknowledge it than zeroing in on 1-2 questionable ones and dissecting them to expose technicalities.
While the individuals writing these books may NOT be too far off Boomers / Gen X age, their 'wisdom' is purely fictional and designed to feed / create the zeitgeist which is the current overly self indulgent population. Humans have been experiencing bad births, poor upbringings, wars since first arriving on the scene. Somehow though, it's only the past 30 - 40 years which appears to have manifested in mass trauma, ADHD, PTSD (and the rest) diagnoses. Interestingly, for about the same length of time that poor ultra processed diets and chemicals have skyrocketed. You're a critical thinker, Joseph, stay that way.
That being said, who says trauma wasnt prevelent before, we just didnt have the luxury to do anything with it or even notice it.
Love this! We were told to just “deal with it” or “get over it” — only in recent years are there safe places and literature to discuss what we’ve known all along. Thanks for this!!
I very honestly feel that I come from a family line, on my maternal side, that embodied PTSD. At my generation, it is epigenetic. Every blasted one of us. It is only at this point that some of us are striving to create a new pattern, or, very frequently, choosing not to have children.
It’s almost as if we’re finally acknowledging it, diagnosing it. In my grandparents generation they just drank themselves to death or killer themselves in record numbers. I find it fascinating that people seeking healing is a problem for you.
Trauma, along with so many new-age problems have blossomed in "first-world" countries over the last few decades. I think there are many causes. First true existential concerns have largely disappeared in western society, the vast majority of people do not have to worry about enough food, water, shelter. We have to find other things to agonize over and there are thousands of experts ready to help us identify them, and by pure coincidence make a solid living from it. And yes, social media plays a role and the unfortunate victims are disproportionately young liberal leaning women. The trauma culture is a real factor and its prevalence varies widely geographically, by sex and by political leaning.
There are many people truly traumatized by serious life altering events and I do not belittle them or doubt that some are never able to identify or acknowledge that fact. For many others I believe the trauma industry is just another escape from agency.
Or, now that people finally feel safe because they dont have to worry about basic life necessities, traumas are coming up. If youre still in survival mode, your body doesnt feel safe to let all the old hurt come up so it can get rid of it. It is only in safety that you can start to notice the trauma that has been present all this time.
It’s almost like our culture has created its own problems which it then promises to be able to fix. Like religion. 🤔
Trauma isn't a 'new-age problem' and it hasn't 'blossomed' over the last few decades. We just have new and better language for the lasting impact of adverse experiences. Yes, Trauma is overused and incorrectly attributed, but that doesn't take away the suffering of anyone who really experiences PTSD. I am grateful I am not in this cohort because I have seen enough of it to understand how debilitating it is.
There are a lot of assumptions and little actual study reflected in this comment. There is a good deal of writing about the psychological effects of various wars on men who returned, as far back as World War I, perhaps further. The symptoms described are consistent with PTSD. There is also evidence of the psychological effects of giving birth in literature such as, “The Yellow Wallpaper,” by Charlotte Perkins Gillman, written in 1892. Similarly, writings about the origins of the novel Frankenstein, and Mary Shelley’s life at that time, show evidence of the psychological impacts of losing a child. Being ignorant of these things does not mean they never happened. They’ve happened for centuries, but only recently been given a name and allowed out of the dark.
Exactly! All this trauma and PTSD bullcrap is the new religion. The same people who shame religions for dogma and "much sky daddy" are the same ones who worship the pseudoscience that is psychology and attack anyone who dares question it. If you have trauma the solution is simple, turn to God, eat well, exercise and live a life of integrity rather than rotting on a couch and taking meds and eating ice cream and slop and spending money on so-called therapy. But apparently such view - common sense - is considered extreme these days. Oh well...
Dont forget the screens
This just in, man disproves the existence of water. Thats how this reads. I can understand if you’re fed up with people branding trauma instead of learning how to clean it up but… I know that water exists.
Ha! To expand, man observes 4x4 patch of asphalt on burning hot day, disproves existence of drowning victims, proposes they were simply born with an unusual non-water fluid already in their lungs, reminds us of the quality evidence base for lung drainage.
What is your issue?
Can there not be a variety of ideas and concepts and interpretations of Trauma? I’ve worked in the field for many years and one thing is very clear - Trauma is a many coloured ‘thing’ and there are various ways to interpret it, work with it and understand it…and if we can gain more insight into it, there is no reason why not…. Rothschild and others have pioneered some (necessary) ways to THINK about trauma and if we become more compassionate and understanding about it, perhaps more people can be helped. Finally, Theory Is only the starting point of training and treatment.
Trauma does to you whatever you do with it. You can use it to grow or you can use it to decay, it's literally that simple. I had an alcoholic abuser buffoon of a father and a shitty childhood, but it eventually lead me to have a life where I work 5-10 hours a week and make more than enough and go wherever, whenever, because I couldn't stand the thought of someone having control over me.
I’m glad to have read your comment as I have achieved things I wanted to despite several health issues and bounced back, up to a point, over the years. Family and emotional issues included. Looking back and feeling satisfied helps me right now but it doesn’t mean the down side isn’t still there and it crops up now and then. Seeing the physiological reasons helps me, but it’s not everyone’s cup of tea for various reasons. I feel it actually helps us. I think that’s one reason my issues were due to my mum who still says never mind after saying how down she feels. I’m seeing her reasons in a different way learning more about what/if/why.
You're right, there absolutely is a downside. But given that we can't change what has already happened, I think it's best to focus on the positives after learning the why - I agree that knowing the cause is important. These days in my opinion way too many people blame trauma for everything negative in their lives and overanalyze, which is understandable up to a level, but taking control over one's life and accepting that messed up things did happen to us yes - but they are in the past now is crucial for a good life, because the future is completely in our control even if it may be hard to admit in some cases. Learning emotional regulation was what helped me most with dealing the downsides of trauma, I highly recommend it to anyone. And thank you for sharing your thoughts!
It’s good to share! I’m sure you know exactly what I mean… Apparently my family look up to me because I’m so chirpy and and deal with my health issues and it helps them to buck up and deal with theirs, right now I’m beginning to think, fine, do what’s good for yourself but I’m not responsible for your emotions! It makes me feel pressured in a way. But definitely loved. This latest almost fashionable way of finding out why you feel like you do and how to deal with it and being broken, needing emotional help to deal with trauma does make me think hopefully it’s just a (money making?) phase, things will settle down again and level out - I mean this in a social psychology way. Hopefully I make sense! Maybe I need more help… 😄
Blaming individuels and pretending that everything is in your hands is at best naïve and totally cruel (why not blaming those who cause trauma and the secondary victimization through mental health systems, institutions, lack of ressources and commmunity...which are failing again and again survivors) and or straight disingenuous. We are fooling ourselves, we have so close to no power on how things are turning and we are often exhausted to chase an illusion of control
Why is it cruel at all? Creating something positive out of something negative is cruel? Maybe you misunderstood what I meant. Either way, I'm not blaming anyone, and I'm not saying that trauma is good - I'm just saying that given that we cannot change the hurtful things that have happened to us in the past, we should focus on the future and do our best and be optimistic, because there is zero downside to that whereas dwelling on the past personally just made me miserable. I do agree that there's a lot wrong with the "system", and that's exactly why we should focus on doing what we can and giving ourselves the best possible life
Very good to read this! But the snowflakes won't like it.
I literally wrote down what happened to me, maybe you should stop replying, because clearly you have no idea what you're replying to (:
It's not about luxury or affordability. He just pulled himself by his bootstraps and worked hard to improve his life instead of being lazy and just feeling like the victim and self-pitying.
Invalidating wasn't my goal, and I agree 100% that trauma does have a lifelong effect. My goal was to say that you get to decide the effect up to a pretty high degree, and can use the "fuel" that it left in a more positive way instead of looking at it as entirely negative, since you can't change the past but the future is in your hands. Your brain chemistry may forever be altered from it, but that's not necessarily an absolute negative. Again, all this said, I understand people who struggle because of trauma because I was one of them for a long time, so I'm not invalidating anything.
I feel like the framing on trauma here is quite narrow
By making the observation/criticism that he defines trauma too broadly?
?
This entire article comes across as smug, reductionist, and clearly written with a tone that's trying to score points rather than genuinely engage with the nuances of trauma research. This is 100% an ego -flex, nothing more.
Happy that the writer doesn't have any patterns that he's struggling with that stem from childhood. Good for him. But please don't project your 'perfect mental health' and lack of any trauma imprints on everyone else still struggling into adulthood with patterns of flight, fright and fawn, that altlhough we're conscious of, we struggle to overcome.